Web PACER (v2.4)

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 1  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                                                            REOPEN (CWx)

                       U.S. District Court

          Central District of California (Western Div.)

 

               CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 97-CV-5306

 

Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                 Filed: 07/18/97

Assigned to: Judge Christina A. Snyder

             Referred to: Discovery Carla M. Woehrle

Demand: $0,000                               Nature of Suit:  820

Lead Docket: None                            Jurisdiction: Federal Question

Dkt # in Western Dist of OK : is 97 CV 299

 

Cause: 17:0101  Copyright Infringement

 

 

WORLDWIDE CHURCH OF GOD           Allan Browne

     plaintiff                    FAX 310-275-5697

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Benjamin D Scheibe

                                  FAX 310-275-5697

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Ella M Martinsen

                                  FAX 310-275-5697

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Sylvia P Lardiere

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Miles J Feldman

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Nick J G Sanchez

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Browne & Woods

                                  450 N Roxbury Dr, 7th Fl

                                  Beverly Hills, CA 90210-4231

                                  310-274-7100

 

                                  Richard Joseph Parent

                                   [term  01/11/99]

                                  Irell & Manella

                                  1800 Avenue of the Stars, Ste

                                  900

                                  Los Angeles, CA 90067-4276

                                  310-277-1010

 

                                  Ralph K Helge

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Ralph K Helge & Associates

                                  440 W Green St

                                  Pasadena, CA 91105

                                  626-304-4000

 

                                  Joseph J Ferretti

                                   [term  07/23/97]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 2  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Courtenay E Parrott

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Crowe & Dunlevy

                                  1800 Mid-America Twr

                                  20 N Broadway Ave

                                  Oklahoma City, OK 73102

                                  405-235-7700

 

 

   v.

 

 

PHILADELPHIA CHURCH OF GOD        Mark B Helm

     defendant                    [COR LD NTC]

                                  Munger Tolles & Olson

                                  355 S Grand Ave, 35th Fl

                                  Los Angeles, CA 90071-1560

                                  213-683-9100

 

                                  Kelly M Klaus

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Kelly M Klaus

                                  (See above)

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Munger Tolles & Olson

                                  33 New Montgomery St, 19th Fl

                                  San Francisco, CA 94105-9781

                                  415-512-4000

 

                                  Marc Edwards

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Kwame T Mumina

                                   [term  04/17/01]

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  A Paul Murrah, Jr

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Phillips McFall McCaffrey McVay

                                  & Murrah

                                  211 N Robinson Ave

                                  Oklahoma City, OK 93102

                                  405-235-4100

 

 

========================

 

 

PHILADELPHIA CHURCH OF GOD        Kelly M Klaus

     counter-claimant             [COR LD NTC]

                                  Munger Tolles & Olson

                                  33 New Montgomery St, 19th Fl

                                  San Francisco, CA 94105-9781

                                  415-512-4000

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 3  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                                  Marc Edwards

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Kwame T Mumina

                                   [term  04/17/01]

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  A Paul Murrah, Jr

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Phillips McFall McCaffrey McVay

                                  & Murrah

                                  211 N Robinson Ave

                                  Oklahoma City, OK 93102

                                  405-235-4100

 

 

   v.

 

 

WORLDWIDE CHURCH OF GOD           Benjamin D Scheibe

     counter-defendant            FAX 310-275-5697

                                  Browne & Woods

                                  450 N Roxbury Dr, 7th Fl

                                  Beverly Hills, CA 90210-4231

                                  310-274-7100

 

                                  Richard Joseph Parent

                                   [term  01/11/99]

                                  Irell & Manella

                                  1800 Avenue of the Stars, Ste

                                  900

                                  Los Angeles, CA 90067-4276

                                  310-277-1010

 

                                  Joseph J Ferretti

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Courtenay E Parrott

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Crowe & Dunlevy

                                  1800 Mid-America Twr

                                  20 N Broadway Ave

                                  Oklahoma City, OK 73102

                                  405-235-7700

 

 

========================

 

 

PHILADELPHIA CHURCH OF GOD        Mark B Helm

     counter-claimant             [COR LD NTC]

                                  Munger Tolles & Olson

                                  355 S Grand Ave, 35th Fl

                                  Los Angeles, CA 90071-1560

                                  213-683-9100

 

                                  Kelly M Klaus


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 4  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Kelly M Klaus

                                  (See above)

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Munger Tolles & Olson

                                  33 New Montgomery St, 19th Fl

                                  San Francisco, CA 94105-9781

                                  415-512-4000

 

                                  Marc Edwards

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Kwame T Mumina

                                   [term  04/17/01]

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  A Paul Murrah, Jr

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Phillips McFall McCaffrey McVay

                                  & Murrah

                                  211 N Robinson Ave

                                  Oklahoma City, OK 93102

                                  405-235-4100

 

 

   v.

 

 

WORLDWIDE CHURCH OF GOD           Allan Browne

     counter-defendant            FAX 310-275-5697

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Benjamin D Scheibe

                                  FAX 310-275-5697

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Miles J Feldman

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Browne & Woods

                                  450 N Roxbury Dr, 7th Fl

                                  Beverly Hills, CA 90210-4231

                                  310-274-7100

 

                                  David Nimmer

                                   [term  11/26/02]

                                  FAX 310-203-7199

                                  Richard Joseph Parent

                                   [term  01/11/99]

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Irell & Manella

                                  1800 Avenue of the Stars, Ste

                                  900

                                  Los Angeles, CA 90067-4276

                                  310-277-1010

 

                                  Ralph K Helge

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Ralph K Helge & Associates


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 5  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                                  440 W Green St

                                  Pasadena, CA 91105

                                  626-304-4000

 

                                  Joseph J Ferretti

                                   [term  07/23/97]

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Courtenay E Parrott

                                  [COR LD NTC]

                                  Crowe & Dunlevy

                                  1800 Mid-America Twr

                                  20 N Broadway Ave

                                  Oklahoma City, OK 73102

                                  405-235-7700

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 6  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

WORLDWIDE CHURCH OF GOD

 

               plaintiff

 

 

   v.

 

PHILADELPHIA CHURCH OF GOD

 

               defendant

 

 

=========================

 

PHILADELPHIA CHURCH OF GOD;

 

               counter-claimant

 

WORLDWIDE CHURCH OF GOD

 

               counter-defendant

 

 

=========================

 

PHILADELPHIA CHURCH OF GOD;

 

               counter-claimant

 

WORLDWIDE CHURCH OF GOD

 

               counter-defendant

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 7  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

3/3/97   1       COMPLAINT (dmjr) [Entry date 07/21/97]

 

3/5/97   2       PRAECIPE: by plaintiff in re complaint [1-1] issd sms (dmjr)

                 [Entry date 07/21/97]

 

3/5/97   5       RETURN and proof of service executed upon defendant

                 Philadelphia Church on 3/3/97 srvd Carol Nash (Gen Agent)

                 by pers srv (dmjr) [Entry date 07/21/97]

 

3/24/97  14      ANSWER to [1-1]  and COUNTERCLAIM by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church against plaintiff Worldwide Church God (dmjr)

                 [Entry date 07/21/97]

 

6/20/97  37      AMENDED COMPLAINT [1-1] by plaintiff Worldwide Church God .

                 Summons not issued (dmjr) [Entry date 07/21/97]

 

7/18/97  --      ORIGINAL file, certified copy of transfer order and docket

                 sheet  received from Western District of Oklahoma (dmjr)

                 [Entry date 07/21/97]

 

7/18/97  --      CASE REFERRED  to Discovery Stephen J. Hillman (dmjr)

                 [Entry date 07/21/97]

 

7/18/97  40      CRT NOTICE of receipt of case transferred in frm West Dist

                 of Oklahoma case # 97 CV 299 M (lc) [Entry date 07/23/97]

 

7/23/97  42      ATTORNEY SUBSTITUTION: terminating attorney Joseph J

                 Ferretti for Worldwide Church God   and substituting

                 attorney Allan Browne  by Judge William D. Keller (pbap)

                 [Entry date 07/25/97]

 

7/24/97  41      ORDER  by Judge William D. Keller re: motion practice. (pbap)

                 [Entry date 07/24/97]

 

7/28/97  43      NOTICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  of related case(s)

                 CV97-875 JSL (jc) [Entry date 07/29/97]

 

7/28/97  44      NOTICE of appearance by defendant Philadelphia Church (lc)

                 [Entry date 07/29/97]

 

8/1/97   45      ANSWER to A/C [37-1]  and COUNTERCLAIM by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church against plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 (pbap) [Entry date 08/04/97]

 

8/6/97   46      Opp to ntc of related case; decl of Benjamin d. Scheibe by

                 plaintiff Worldwide Church God (pbap) [Entry date 08/07/97]

 

8/8/97   49      NOTICE of assn of cnsl Ralph K Helge  by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God (lc) [Entry date 08/21/97]

 

8/8/97   50      NOTICE of approval of subst of atty by Worldwide Church God

                 (lc) [Entry date 08/21/97]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 8  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

8/12/97  48      REPLY by defendant Philadelphia Church to opp to ntc of

                 related case [43-1] (dh) [Entry date 08/20/97]

 

8/15/97  51      SURREPLY by plaintiff Worldwide Church God re ntc of

                 related case [43-1] (lc) [Entry date 08/21/97]

 

8/19/97  47      ORDER RE TRANSFER PURSUANT TO GENERAL ORDER 224 (Related

                 Case) filed. [ Related Case no.: CV97-875 JSL (CWx)] Case

                 transferred from Judge William D. Keller  to Judge J. S.

                 Letts  for all further proceedings. The case number will

                 now reflect the initials of the transferee Judge [

                 CV97-5306 JSL (CWx)]., Case referred from Discovery

                 Stephen J. Hillman to Discovery Carla M. Woehrle .  (cc:

                 all counsel) (jc) [Entry date 08/19/97]

 

8/25/97  52      STIPULATION and ORDER tht any plfd or mot resp to dft

                 Philadelphia's ans & cntclm tht is fld & svd by Worldwide

                 Church of God on/bef 8/28/97, shall be considered timely

                 under Rule 15. This stip shall not be construed as a waiver

                 by dft Philadelphia of any challenge or arg it would have

                 had against a resp ldgd or mot fld by Worldwide Church

                 on/bef 8/18/97 by Judge J. S. Letts (lori)

                 [Entry date 08/25/97]

 

8/28/97  53      NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to dismiss, and/or to strike (lk) [Entry date 09/04/97]

 

9/12/97  54      ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts  re Informal status conference

                  status conference set on 3:00 9/25/97 (lk)

                 [Entry date 09/15/97]

 

9/15/97  55      STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge J. S. Letts resetting

                 hearing on plf's motion to dismiss [53-1] &/or motion to

                 strike [53-2] 1:00 10/6/97; dft Philadelphia Church shall

                 fi its memo in oppo ntl 9/18/97; plf shall fi a reply memo,

                 if any, to the oppo ntl 9/29/97. (lori)

                 [Entry date 09/16/97]

 

9/17/97  56      NOTICE of informal status conf by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God (pbap) [Entry date 09/18/97]

 

9/18/97  57       Opposition by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion to

                 dismiss [53-1], motion to strike [53-2] (lk)

                 [Entry date 09/19/97]

 

9/29/97  58      REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support re

                 [53-1], re [53-2] (lk) [Entry date 09/30/97]

 

10/3/97  59      MINUTES: plf's motion to dismiss [53-1], &/or to strike

                 [53-2] is gr in part and den in part by Judge J. S. Letts

                 CR: N/A (lori) [Entry date 10/14/97]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 9  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

10/8/97  60      ORDER by Judge J. S. Letts GRANT in part DENY in part

                 plaintiffs motion to dismiss [53-1], GRANT in part DENY in

                 part plaintiffs motion to strike [53-2].  (ENT 10/15/97)

                 mld cpy/ntc. (lk) [Entry date 10/15/97]

 

11/14/97 --      REPORT ON THE FILING OF AN ACTION REGARDING cpyright (cc:

                 form mailed to Washington, D.C.)(Opening) (ab)

                 [Entry date 11/17/97]

 

11/19/97 61      ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM [45-2] by counter-defendant

                 Worldwide Church God (lk) [Entry date 11/20/97]

 

11/24/97 62      NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to certify Order for interlocutory appeal pursuant to

                 28 USC 1291(b) ; motion hearing set for 1:00 1/5/98; Memo

                 of P/A's; decl of Benjamin D Scheibe; and exh in support

                 thereof. (lk) [Entry date 12/01/97]

 

11/24/97 63      NOTICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God's position re

                 Motion to compel set by Philadelphia Church of God for

                 Telephonic hrg. (lk) [Entry date 12/01/97]

 

12/15/97 64      AMENDED and CORRECTED Ntc of motion and Mot to Certify by

                 plaintiff Worldwide Church God to [62-1]; decl of Ella M

                 Martinsen; and exhibits in support thereof. (lk)

                 [Entry date 12/16/97]

 

12/22/97 65      NOTICE OF CONDITIONAL MOTION AND CONDTITIONAL MOTION by

                 defendant Philadelphia Church to certify ord for

                 interlocutory Appeal purs to 28 USC sect 1992(b); motion

                 hearing set for 1:00 1/20/98 (lori) [Entry date 12/24/97]

 

12/22/97 66      Memo of PA by defendant Philadelphia Church in oppo to to

                 motion to certify Order for interlocutory appeal pursuant

                 to 28 USC 1291(b) [62-1] & in suppt of dft's conditional

                 mot. (lori) [Entry date 12/24/97]

 

12/22/97 66      & MEMORANDUM of PA by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 support of motion to certify ord for interlocutory Appeal

                 purs to 28 USC sect 1992(b) [65-1] (lori)

                 [Entry date 12/24/97]

 

12/22/97 67      DECLARATION of Kelly M Klaus by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in suppt of memo in suppt re [66-1], [66-1] (lori)

                 [Entry date 12/24/97]

 

12/29/97 68      REPLY BRIEF by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support o

                 Mot to certify Ord re [62-1] (lk) [Entry date 12/30/97]

 

1/5/98   69      Ressp by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to dft's

                 "Conditional" motion to certify ord for interlocutory

                 Appeal purs to 28 USC sect 1992(b) [65-1] (lori)

                 [Entry date 01/06/98]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 10  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

1/5/98   72      MINUTES:  crt den plf's otion to certify Order for

                 interlocutory appeal pursuant to 28 USC 1291(b) [62-1] by

                 Judge J. S. Letts CR: Terry Kramer (lori)

                 [Entry date 01/12/98]

 

1/7/98   70      NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL by counter-claimant, defendant

                 Philadelphia Church of God, withdrawing motion to certify

                 ord for interlocutory Appeal purs to 28 USC sect 1992(b)

                 [65-1] (lk) [Entry date 01/09/98]

 

1/7/98   71      ORDER by Judge J. S. Letts denying plf's motion to certify

                 Order for interlocutory appeal pursuant to 28 USC 1291(b)

                 [62-1] (Ent 1/12/98), mld cpies & nots. (lori)

                 [Entry date 01/12/98]

 

1/12/98  102     SUPPL DECLARATION  of Benjamin D Scheibe by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God in support re motion for partial

                 summary judgment [100-1]  (Exhibits W-Z) (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/13/99]

 

3/9/98   74      NOTICE by defendant Philadelphia Church of entry of Order.

                 (lk) [Entry date 03/10/98]

 

3/16/98  75      NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church to compel re: redacted docs and production of doc

                 and creation of privilege log; motion hearing set for 1:00

                 3/30/98. (ab) [Entry date 03/18/98]

 

3/16/98  --      LODGED/PROPOSED ORDER submitted by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church for motion to compel re: redacted docs and

                 production of doc and creation of privilege log [75-1]

                 .(FWD TO CRD) (ab) [Entry date 03/18/98]

 

3/16/98  76      JOINT STIPULATION re [75-1] (ab) [Entry date 03/18/98]

 

3/16/98  77      JOINT STIPULATION re [75-1] (ab) [Entry date 03/18/98]

 

3/16/98  78      PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 3/16/98 of ntc of mot and mot to compel redacted docs and

                 production of docs and creations of privilege log; jnt stip

                 re mot; propd ord GR dft mot to compel. (ab)

                 [Entry date 03/18/98]

 

3/24/98  79      Suppl memo by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in opposition

                 to motion to compel re: production of doc and creation of

                 privilege log [75-1]; decl of Ella M Martinsen. (lk)

                 [Entry date 03/26/98] [Edit date 03/26/98]

 

3/24/98  80       Suppl memo by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in opposition

                 to motion to compel re: redacted docs  [75-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 03/26/98]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 11  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

4/1/98   81      NOTICE OF ASSOCIATION of Counsel for counter-defendant

                 Worldwide Church God, counter-defendant Worldwide Church

                 God, plaintiff Worldwide Church God by attorney David

                 Nimmer, Richard Joseph Parent (dmjr) [Entry date 04/02/98]

 

4/1/98   82      NOTICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God of cont of dft

                 Philadelphia Church of God Inc's mots to comp re R [1]

                 redacted docs; and [2] prod of docs and creation of priv

                 log. (lk) [Entry date 04/02/98]

 

4/17/98  84      MINUTES:  granting  motion to compel re: redacted docs and

                 production of doc and creation of privilege log [75-1]

                 andwill appoinga special master by Judge J. S. Letts  CR:

                 Terry Kramer  See Order. (lk) [Entry date 04/24/98]

 

4/21/98  83      ORDER by Judge J. S. Letts granting dft's motion to compel

                 re: redacted docs and production of doc and creation of

                 privilege log [75-1] & ord re appt of Special Master. Plf

                 shall turn over to the Special Master, immediately upon

                 his/her appt by the crt, both a redacted & unredacted set

                 of ea doc tht has been redacted by plfs. (lori)

                 [Entry date 04/23/98]

 

5/1/98   85      NOTICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God of Good Faith

                 Compliance with CourtOrder dated 4/21/98 re [83-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/05/98]

 

5/28/98  86      Not of retention of Speical Master purs to crt ord & ord

                 thereon. Purs to the crt ord dtd 4/21/98, the pties have

                 selected the Hon Eli Chernow, Retired Judge of the Superior

                 Crt, to serve as Special Master by Judge J. S. Letts (lori)

                 [Entry date 06/02/98] [Edit date 06/02/98]

 

8/4/98   87      MEMORANDUM of PA IN SUPPORT of mot for sanctions against

                 plf Worldwide Church of God for doc redactions by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church of (lori) [Entry date 08/10/98]

 

8/17/98  88      REPLY by plaintiff Worldwide Church God memorandum of P/A's

                 in support of redactions made to protect the privacy rights

                 of third parties. (lk) [Entry date 08/19/98]

 

11/30/98 89      ORDERS FOR COURT TRIAL  by Judge J. S. Letts setting ;

                 discovery ddl set on 3/15/99 ; pretrial conference on 8:00

                 4/2/99 ;trial set on 9:00 4/13/99 (lk) [Entry date 12/04/98]

 

1/6/99   90      STIPULATION and ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts re BVrief sched

                 and page limits.  The brief sched on ptys X-motfor sum adj

                 will be as follows:  Mot will be fi NLT 1/6/99; oppos due

                 1/19/99; rply br NLT 1/25/99; and hrg will be 2/1/99.  The

                 open and oppos br shall not exceed 40 pgs and rply br shall

                 not exceed 25 pgs. (lk) [Entry date 01/07/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 12  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

1/11/99  91      NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for preliminary injunction ; motion hearing set for

                 1:00 2/8/99.   Decl of Benjamin D Scheibe and exhibit in

                 support.  Lodged Order (lk) [Entry date 01/12/99]

 

1/11/99  92      NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church of God Inc for summary adjudication ; motion

                 hearing set for 1:00 2/8/99   Lodged Stmt of Facts & Order

                 (lk) [Entry date 01/12/99]

 

1/11/99  93      DECLARATION  of Ron Fraser by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 in support re motion for summary adjudication [92-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/12/99]

 

1/11/99  94      DECLARATION  of Gerald Flurry by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support re motion for summary adjudication [92-1]

                 (lk) [Entry date 01/12/99]

 

1/11/99  95      PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 1/11/99  of Ntc of Motion and Mot for sum adj; memo in

                 support; decls in support; stmt of U/F; Prop Jgmt (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/12/99]

 

1/11/99  98      PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 1/11/99  of Ntc of mot and mof for Partial sum jgm, decls

                 in support, stmt of U/F, suppl decl; Ntc of mot and mot for

                 P/I, prop P/I Order. (lk) [Entry date 01/12/99]

 

1/11/99  99      ATTORNEY SUBSTITUTION: terminating attorney Richard Joseph

                 Parent for Worldwide Church God by counter-defendant,

                 plaintiff and substituting attorney Benjamin D Scheibe by

                 Judge J. S. Letts (lk) [Entry date 01/13/99]

 

1/12/99  100     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for partial summary judgment ; motion hearing set for

                 1:00 2/8/99 (lk) [Entry date 01/13/99]

 

1/12/99  101     DECLARATION  of Benjamin D Scheibe by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God in support re motion for partial summary

                 judgment [100-1] Vol II -- Exhibits S thru V (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/13/99]

 

1/12/99  103     DECLARATION  of Benjamin D Scheibe by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God in support re motion for partial summary

                 judgment [100-1]  Vol I -- Exhibits A through R (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/13/99]

 

1/12/99  104     DECLARATIONS  of Aaron Dean, Dexter Falkner, Shari Haber,

                 Ralph K Helge, Herman L Hoeh, Roger Lippross, Gene Michel,

                 Mathew Morgan, Leroy Neff, Oliver B Nesmith, Lawrence

                 Omasta, Richard Rice, Joanne Scala, Janet Shay, Fred

                 Stevens and Allan Browne  by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 in support re motion for partial summary judgment [100-1]

                 (lk) [Entry date 01/13/99]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 13  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

1/12/99  105     DECLARATION  of Benjamin D Scheibe by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God in support re motion for partial summary

                 judgment [100-1]   Vol III -- Exhibits 1, 3, 5, 8, 1001,

                 and 1020. (lk) [Entry date 01/13/99]

 

1/12/99  106     PROOF OF PERSONAL SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 on 1/11/99 of mot for partial sum jgm, Mot for P/I and all

                 related documents. (lk) [Entry date 01/13/99]

 

1/12/99  102     SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION of Benjamin D Scheibe by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God in support re motion for partial

                 summary judgment [100-1]. (Exh W-Z) (lk)

                 [Entry date 06/24/99]

 

1/13/99  107     PROOF OF PERSONAL SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 on 1/12/99 of Prop Judgment following Pla mot for partial

                 sum jgm. (lk) [Entry date 01/14/99]

 

1/22/99  108     STIPULATION and ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts that the follow

                 deadlines may and hereby are ext as follows:  1.  The ti in

                 whi to exchange initial exp wit infor shall be to and until

                 March 1, 1999;  2.. Time in whi to exchange resp expert

                 witn info shall be ext to and until March 15, 1999;   The

                 date by whi the ptys shall complete their exp wit depos

                 shall be ext to March 29, 1999. (lk) [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  109      Evidentiary objections by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 todecl of Mark Helm in support of dft Philadephia Chursh of

                 God's motion for summary adjudication [92-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  110      Evidentiary objections by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 todecl of Ron Fraser in support of motion for summary

                 adjudication [92-1] (lk) [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  112     DECLARATION  of Clarice Crossen by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God in opposition re motion for summary adjudication

                 [92-1] (lk) [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  113     SUPPL DECLARATION of Ralph K Helge by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God in opposition to dfts motion for summary

                 adjudication [92-1] (lk) [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  115     Memo of P/A's in OPPOSITION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to motion for summary adjudication [92-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  116     DECLARATION  of Dan Rogers by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in opposition re motion for summary adjudication [92-1]

                 (lk) [Entry date 01/25/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 14  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

1/25/99  117     DECLARATION  of Benjamin D Scheibe by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God filed in oppos re motion for summary

                 adjudication [92-1]; Volume II - Exhibits HH through LL. (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  119     DECLARATION  of Aaron Dean, Dexter Falkner, Shari Haber,

                 Ralph K Helge, Herman L Hoeh, Roger Lippross, Gene Michel,

                 Mathew Morgan, Leroy Neff, Oliver B Nesmith, Lawrence

                 Omasta, Richard Rice, Joanne Scala, Janet Shay, Fred

                 Stevens and Allan Browne  by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 filed in oppos re motion for summary adjudication [92-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  121     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 1/25/99 memo of P/A's in oppos to dfts mot for sum adj,

                 stmt of genuine issues, oppos to mot; evidentiary obj,

                 decls, suppl decl. (lk) [Entry date 01/25/99]

 

1/25/99  122     STATEMENT of Genuine Issues by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support of opposition to motion for partial

                 summary judgment [100-1] (lk) [Entry date 01/26/99]

 

1/25/99  123     SUPPL DECLARATION of Mark B Helm by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in opposition re motion for partial summary judgment

                 [100-1], motion for preliminary injunction [91-1], and in

                 further support of motion for summary adjudication [92-1]

                 (lk) [Entry date 01/26/99]

 

1/25/99  124     Memo of P/A's in OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church to motion for preliminary injunction [91-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/26/99]

 

1/25/99  127     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 1/25/99 of memo of P/A's in oppos to mot for partial sum

                 jgm, decls in oppos and in support of motions, Stmt of

                 genuine issues in support and in oppos to motions. (lk)

                 [Entry date 01/26/99]

 

1/26/99  128     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 1/25/99 by pers svc of oppos to dfts mot for sum adj and

                 all related documents. (lk) [Entry date 01/26/99]

 

1/27/99  129     DECLARATION  of Dan Rogers by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in opposition re motion for summary adjudication [92-1]

                 (lk) [Entry date 01/29/99]

 

2/1/99   130     REPLY by defendant Philadelphia Church in support of dfts

                 motion for summary adjudication [92-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 02/03/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 15  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

2/1/99   131      Evidentiary obj by defendant Philadelphia Church to

                 materials busm with Pltfs motions for partial sum jgm and

                 P/I and oppos to dfts mot for sum adj re  motion for

                 partial summary judgment [100-1], motion for summary

                 adjudication [92-1], motion for preliminary injunction

                 [91-1] (lk) [Entry date 02/03/99]

 

2/1/99   133      Evidentiary Objections by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 to "Suppl decl of Gerald Flurry in oppos to pltf mot for

                 partial sum and and P/I and in further support of dfts mot

                 for sum adj" to motion for partial summary judgment

                 [100-1], motion for summary adjudication [92-1], motion for

                 preliminary injunction [91-1] (lk) [Entry date 02/03/99]

 

2/1/99   134      Evidentiary Objections  by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 to "Suppl decl of Mark Helm in Oppos to pltf mot for

                 partial sum jgm and for P/I and in further support of dfts

                 mot for sum adj" to motion for partial summary judgment

                 [100-1], motion for summary adjudication [92-1], motion for

                 preliminary injunction [91-1] (lk) [Entry date 02/03/99]

 

2/1/99   135     REPLY by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 motion for preliminary injunction [91-1]; decl of Benjamin

                 D Scheibe in support. (lk) [Entry date 02/03/99]

 

2/1/99   138     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 2/1/99 of Rply memos in support of mot for partial sum jgm;

                 for prel inj; and related docs. (lk) [Entry date 02/03/99]

 

2/2/99   139     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 2/1/99 by personal service of Pltfs rply memo in support of

                 motfor patrial sum jgm; rply in support of mot for P/I; and

                 related documents. (lk) [Entry date 02/04/99]

 

2/4/99   --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED - Prel Inj  Prop. (lk)

                 [Entry date 02/08/99]

 

2/4/99   --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED - Prop Jgm follow pltfs mot for

                 partial sum jgm. (lk) [Entry date 02/08/99]

 

2/5/99   140     OBJECTIONS TO MATERIALS subm w/plf reply memo in suppt by

                 Philadelphia Church to motion for partial summary judgment

                 [100-1], motion for injunction [91-1]; decl of Kelly M

                 Klaus (lc) [Entry date 02/09/99]

 

2/8/99   141     MINUTES:  granting dfts motion for summary adjudication

                 [92-1], denying pltfs motion for preliminary injunction

                 [91-1] by Judge J. S. Letts  CR: Terry Kramer (lk)

                 [Entry date 02/16/99]

 

3/10/99  142     Notice of lodging ff & ord by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 to motion for partial summary judgment [100-1], motion for

                 summary adjudication [92-1], motion for preliminary

                 injunction [91-1] (lc) [Entry date 03/11/99]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 16  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

3/10/99  --      LODGED ff & ord submitted by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 (FWD TO CRD) (lc) [Entry date 03/11/99]

 

3/10/99  143     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 3/10/99  of ntc of lodging ff and ord by personal srv (lc)

                 [Entry date 03/11/99]

 

3/31/99  144     OBJECTIONS by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to findings of

                 fact & concl of law & order on motion for partial summary

                 judgment [100-1], motion for summary adjudication [92-1],

                 motion for preliminary injunction [91-1] (jag)

                 [Entry date 04/02/99]

 

4/9/99   145     OBJECTIONS by counter-defendant Worldwide Church God,

                 counter-defendant Worldwide Church God, plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God to Prop Ord on (1) Pltfs mot for partial sum jgm;

                  (2) dfts motforsum adj; and (3) pltf mot for P/I; decl of

                 Sylvia P Lardiere in support. (lk) [Entry date 04/12/99]

 

4/13/99  --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED - Stmt of U/F & C/Law in support

                 of dfts mot for sum adj. (lk) [Entry date 04/15/99]

 

4/13/99  --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED - Pltf stmt of U/F & C/Law. (lk)

                 [Entry date 04/15/99]

 

4/13/99  --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED - Prop F/F C/Law and ORd on pltf

                 mot for partial sum jgm; dfts mot for sum adj; pltf mot for

                 P/I. (lk) [Entry date 04/15/99]

 

4/13/99  --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED -Prop Jgmt follow dfts Mot for

                 sum adj. (lk) [Entry date 04/15/99]

 

4/15/99  146     ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts  denying pltfs motion for

                 partial summary judgment [100-1], denying pltfs motion for

                 preliminary injunction [91-1], granting dfts motion for

                 summary adjudication [92-1]  trial vacated and disc is

                 stayed pending resol of any appeals.  (ENT 4/20/99)  mld

                 cpy/ntc. (lk) [Entry date 04/20/99]

 

4/30/99  147     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for order amend jgm ent 4/20/99 and Granting Inj

                 pending appeal ; motion hearing set for 1:00 6/14/99. Memo

                 of P/A's; decl of Ralph K Helge and Benjamin D Schiebe in

                 support.  Lodged (2) Prop ORds (lk) [Entry date 05/03/99]

 

5/3/99   148     AMENDED NOTICE OF motion & motion for order amend jgm ent

                 4/20/99 and Granting Inj pending appeal [147-1], corrected

                 mot hrg date is 6/14/99 at 1:00, filed by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God (jj) [Entry date 05/05/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 17  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

5/3/99   149     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 4/30/99 of ntc of mot & mot for ord (1) amd jgm ent

                 4/20/99, & (2) GR inj pending appeal; memo of P/A & decls

                 of Ralph K Helge & Benjamin D Schiebe in suppt thereof (jj)

                 [Entry date 05/05/99]

 

5/3/99   150     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 4/30/99 of [alternative] ord (1) amd jgm ent 4/20/99, & (2)

                 GR inj pending appeal [propsd] (jj) [Entry date 05/05/99]

 

5/3/99   151     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 4/30/99 of ord (1) amd jgm ent 4/20/99, & (2) GR inj

                 pending appeal [propsd] (jj) [Entry date 05/05/99]

 

5/4/99   153     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church for attorney fees purs to 17 USC 505 ; motion

                 hearing set for 1:00 6/1/99 Lodged Prop Order (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/06/99]

 

5/4/99   154     MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT by defendant Philadelphia Church  of

                 motion for attorney fees [153-1] (lk) [Entry date 05/06/99]

 

5/4/99   155     DECLARATION  of Kelly M Klaus by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support re motion for attorney fees [153-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/06/99]

 

5/4/99   156     DECLARATION  of Mark B Helm by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support re motion for attorney fees [153-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/06/99]

 

5/4/99   157     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 5/4/99  of Ntc of mot for atty fees, memo in support, decls

                 in supp, Prop Ord (lk) [Entry date 05/06/99]

 

5/5/99   152     Ntc ofappl and appl toclerk of Crt to tax costs; BILL OF

                 COSTS RETURNABLE submitted by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 ; bill of cost hearing set on 10:00 5/19/99 (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/06/99]

 

5/12/99  158     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for order cont hrg dates based upon unavailability of

                 pltf cnsl , referring valuation issues arising under dfts

                 mot for atty fees to a special master; decl of Sylvia P

                 Lardiere in support.  Lodged Prop ORder (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/13/99]

 

5/12/99  159     OBJECTIONS by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to bill of

                 costs re [152-1] (lk) [Entry date 05/13/99]

 

5/12/99  160     OPPOSITION by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  to

                 application to tax costs re  bill of costs [152-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/13/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 18  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

5/13/99  161     DECLARATION  of Kelly M Klaus by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support ofdfts opposition  re exparte motion for

                 order cont hrg dates based upon unavailability of pltf cnsl

                 [158-1], exparte motion referring valuation issues arising

                 under dfts mot for atty fees to a special master [158-2] (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/17/99]

 

5/13/99  162     REPLY BRIEF by plaintiff Worldwide Church God filed in

                 support of exparte motion for order cont hrg dates based

                 upon unavailability of pltf cnsl [158-1], exparte motion

                 referring valuation issues arising under dfts mot for atty

                 fees to a special master [158-2] (lk) [Entry date 05/17/99]

 

5/13/99  163     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church  to exparte

                 motion for order cont hrg dates based upon unavailability

                 of pltf cnsl [158-1], exparte motion referring valuation

                 issues arising under dfts mot for atty fees to a special

                 master [158-2] (lk) [Entry date 05/17/99]

 

5/13/99  164     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 5/13/99  of Oppos to ex parte appl, decl of Kelly M Klaus,

                 Prop Ord. (lk) [Entry date 05/17/99]

 

5/13/99  --      LODGED/PROPOSED ORDER submitted by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church for exparte motion for order cont hrg dates based

                 upon unavailability of pltf cnsl [158-1], for exparte

                 motion referring valuation issues arising under dfts mot

                 for atty fees to a special master [158-2] .(FWD TO CRD) (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/17/99]

 

5/14/99  165     PROOF OF SERVICE by personal service by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God on 5/12/99  of Ex parte appl for cont hrg dates

                 based upon unavailabilty of pltfs cnsl ; and referring

                 valuation issues arising under atty fees to special master;

                 decl. (lk) [Entry date 05/17/99] [Edit date 05/17/99]

 

5/14/99  166     PROOF OF personal SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 on 5/12/99  of Ord gr ex parte for ORd cont hrg dates and

                 referring valuation issues arising under dfts mot for atty

                 fees to special master. (lk) [Entry date 05/17/99]

 

5/18/99  167     MEMO OF P/A'S submitted IN OPPOSITION by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God to motion for attorney fees [153-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/20/99]

 

5/19/99  170     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 5/18/99  of Memo of P/A in opposition to mot for atty fees.

                 (lk) [Entry date 05/20/99]

 

5/19/99  --      COSTS taxed for defendant Philadelphia Church  in the

                 amount of $ 6,166.90 against plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 ; bill of cost hearing held (lk) [Entry date 05/24/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 19  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

5/20/99  168     PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION APPEAL by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to 9th C/A from Dist. Court ord ent 4/20/99 [146-2]

                 (cc: Browne & Woods;Ralph K. Helge;Munger,Tolles & Olson;

                 Munger,Tolles & Olson ) Fee: Paid. (ghap)

                 [Entry date 05/20/99]

 

5/20/99  169     REPRESENTATION STATEMENT re appeal [168-1] (ghap)

                 [Entry date 05/20/99]

 

5/20/99  171     NOTICE by defendant Philadelphia Church ofentry of bill of

                 costs. (lk) [Entry date 05/21/99]

 

5/24/99  174     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to retax costs ; motion hearing set for 1:00 6/14/99 (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/26/99]

 

5/25/99  --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED - Ord amend jgm ent 4/20/99 and

                 gr injunction pending appeal (prop). (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/27/99]

 

5/25/99  --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED- Amend Ordamd jgm and gr Injunct

                 pending appeal (lk) [Entry date 05/27/99]

 

5/26/99  172     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 1/5/98,2/8/99  CR: Terry Kramer (ghap) [Entry date 05/26/99]

 

5/26/99  173     NOTIFICATION by Circuit Court of Appellate Docket Number

                 appeal [168-1] 99-55850 (ghap) [Entry date 05/26/99]

 

5/26/99  175     CORRECTED REPRESENTATION STMT  by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God correcting service list showing all of ptys to

                 the actn. (lk) [Entry date 05/27/99]

 

5/27/99  176     OBJECTIONS by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to [Revised

                 Proposed] Ord following telephonic hearing (lk)

                 [Entry date 05/28/99]

 

5/27/99  177     NOTICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God of continuance of

                 mot of pltf to retax costs. (lk) [Entry date 05/28/99]

 

5/27/99  184     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 1/5/98, 2/8/99 (Re: [168-1] )  CR: Terry Kramer

                 (wdc) [Entry date 06/02/99]

 

5/27/99  --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 1/5/98 (wdc)

                 [Entry date 06/02/99]

 

5/27/99  --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 2/8/99 (wdc)

                 [Entry date 06/02/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 20  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

5/28/99  178     ORDER following telephonic hearing by Judge J. S. Letts

                 denying motion for order amend jgm ent 4/20/99 and Granting

                 Inj pending appeal [147-1], denying motion for preliminary

                 injunction [91-1], resetting hearing on motion for attorney

                 fees [153-1] 6/28/99, resetting hearing on motion to retax

                 costs [174-1] 6/28/99 (bg) [Entry date 06/01/99]

 

5/28/99  179     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 2/18/97(orig in case CV 97-875), 11/25/97, 4/17/98  CR:

                 Terry Kramer (fvap) [Entry date 06/01/99]

 

5/28/99  180     RESPONSE  by defendant Philadelphia Church to pltfs obj to

                 Prop Ord follow telephonic hrg re objection [176-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 06/01/99]

 

5/28/99  181     NOTICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God of portions of

                 transcript it intends to Ord and stmt of issues it intends

                 to present on appeal. (lk) [Entry date 06/01/99]

 

5/28/99  --      PLACED IN FILE - NOT USED- Prop Ord follow telephonic hrg.

                 (lk) [Entry date 06/01/99]

 

6/1/99   182     CORRECTED TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for

                 dates: 2/18/97, 11/25/97, 4/17/98  CR: Terry Kramer (pjap)

                 [Entry date 06/02/99] [Edit date 06/02/99]

 

6/2/99   183     CERTIFIED COPY  ORDER FROM USCA ptnr's mot for lve to file

                 a reply brief is denied. Respondent's opp mot to strike

                 ptnr's repy is gr. Ptn for perm to app pursuant to 28 USC

                 1292(b) is gr. W/i 10 dys of ord, ptnr shall perfect app

                 pursuant to FRAP 5(d). Respondent's req to cert the dist

                 crt's 10/15/97 ord is denied.(app under 1292(b)is frm cert

                 ord, not frm any other ord(s) that may have been ent in

                 case).  rejects responden't asseertion the dist crt

                 implicitly cert 10/15/97 ord. Respondent may seek a written

                 ord frm dist crt in that regard & may then file ptn for

                 perm to app with this crt. Ptnr has stated it intends to

                 app the dist crt's 4/20/99 ord following dist crt's dispo

                 of FRACP 59(e) mot. Accordingly crt stays briefing in cert

                 app pndng dispo of mot for recons by dist crt/ W/i 21 dys

                 of dist crt's ord, ptnr shall notify crt in writing of dist

                 crt's determ of mot for reconsid & of any noa that has been

                 filed re ord. Ptnr also shall file a mot to consolidate at

                 that time. (99-80093) (fvap) [Entry date 06/02/99]

 

6/2/99   185     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 2/18/97, 11/25/97, 1/5/98, 4/17/98, 2/8/99  CR: Terry

                 Kramer (dl) [Entry date 06/03/99]

 

6/3/99   186     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 to amend Crt's 10/15/99 Ord to expressly provide for

                 certification  under 28 USC. Lodged Prop Order (lk)

                 [Entry date 06/04/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 21  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

6/3/99   187     DECLARATION  of Mark B Helm by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support re exparte motion to amend Crt's 10/15/99

                 Ord to expressly provide for certification [186-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 06/04/99]

 

6/3/99   --      Appeal Fee Paid  fee  in amount of $ 105.00 (99-55934) (fvap)

                 [Entry date 06/11/99]

 

6/3/99   191     REPRESENTATION STATEMENT re (99-55934), Munger, Tolles &

                 Olson, Los Angeles, CA; Munger, Tolles & Olson, San

                 Francisco, CA; Brown & Woods, Beverly Hills, CA; Ralph K.

                 Helge, Pasadena, CA) (fvap) [Entry date 06/11/99]

 

6/3/99   192     Notice Transc to be Ordered/St appeal order [183-1],

                 document appeal [0-0], statement [190-1] (fvap)

                 [Entry date 06/11/99]

 

6/3/99   193     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 2/18/97, 1/5/98, 2/8/99 re  transcript [0-0], re

                 transcript [0-0] CR: Terry Kramer (99-55934) (fvap)

                 [Entry date 06/11/99]

 

6/4/99   188     OPPOSITION by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  to exparte

                 motion to amend Crt's 10/15/99 Ord to expressly provide for

                 certification [186-1] (lk) [Entry date 06/07/99]

 

6/4/99   195     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 2/18/97,11/25/97,4/17/98 (Re: [189-1], [168-1] )

                 CR: Terry Kramer(Originally Case No. CV-97-875-JSL) (ghap)

                 [Entry date 06/14/99]

 

6/7/99   189     NOTICE OF APPEAL by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to 9th

                 C/A from Dist. Court ord fld 5/28/99 [178-1]  (cc: Browne &

                 Woods;Ralph K. Helge;Munger,Tolles & Olson;Munger,Tolles &

                 Olson ) Fee: Paid. (ghap) [Entry date 06/08/99]

 

6/7/99   190     REPRESENTATION STATEMENT re appeal [189-1] (ghap)

                 [Entry date 06/08/99]

 

6/11/99  194     NOTIFICATION by Circuit Court of Appellate Docket Number

                 99-55934 (1292 app, fld dte 5/27/99) (fvap)

                 [Entry date 06/11/99]

 

6/14/99  196     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church  to motion to

                 retax costs [174-1] (lk) [Entry date 06/15/99]

 

6/14/99  197     SUPPLEMENTAL MEMO OF P/A's IN OPPOSITION by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God to motion for attorney fees [153-1];

                 decl of Sylvia P Lardiere in support thereof. (lk)

                 [Entry date 06/15/99]

 

6/15/99  198     PROOF OF SERVICE by pers svc  by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God on 6/14/99  of Suppl memo of P/A's sbm by pltf in

                 opposition to mot for atty fees. (lk) [Entry date 06/15/99]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 22  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

6/21/99  199     SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION  of Mark B Helm by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church in support re motion for attorney fees

                 [153-1] (lk) [Entry date 06/22/99]

 

6/21/99  200     REPLY Memo by defendant Philadelphia Church in support of

                 motion for attorney fees [153-1] (lk) [Entry date 06/22/99]

 

6/21/99  201     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 motion to retax costs [174-1] (lk) [Entry date 06/22/99]

 

6/23/99  202      Notice of portions of transc intends to ord appeal order

                 [183-1] (dl) [Entry date 06/25/99]

 

6/23/99  203     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 11/25/97, 4/17/98  CR: Terry Kramer (dl)

                 [Entry date 06/25/99]

 

6/23/99  204     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 2/18/97, 1/5/98, 2/8/99  CR: Terry Kramer (dl)

                 [Entry date 06/25/99]

 

6/23/99  206     Notice of portions of transcs aplle intend to ord appeal

                 order [183-1] (dl) [Entry date 06/28/99]

 

6/23/99  207     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 11/25/97, 4/17/98  CR: Terry Kramer (dl)

                 [Entry date 06/28/99]

 

6/25/99  205     NOTICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God of cont of hrg on

                 dfts mot for atty fees and pltfs mot to retax costs. (lk)

                 [Entry date 06/28/99]

 

6/28/99  208     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 11/25/97, 4/17/98 CR: Terry Kramer (weap)

                 [Entry date 06/28/99]

 

6/30/99  209     NOTIFICATION by Circuit Court of Appellate Docket Number

                 appeal [189-1] (99-56005) (wdc) [Entry date 06/30/99]

 

7/2/99   210     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 2/18/97,11/25/97,1/5/98,4/17/98,2/8/99 re  transcript

                 [195-1] CR: Terry Kramer (ghap) [Entry date 07/02/99]

 

7/6/99   211     CERTIFICATE of Record Transmitted to USCA (99-55850) (cc:

                 all parties) (pjap) [Entry date 07/06/99]

 

7/6/99   212     CERTIFICATE of Record Transmitted to USCA (99-55934) (cc:

                 all parties) (pjap) [Entry date 07/06/99]

 

7/6/99   213     CERTIFICATE of Record Transmitted to USCA (99-56005) (cc:

                 all parties) (pjap) [Entry date 07/06/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 23  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

7/7/99   215     ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts  granting PCG's exparte motion

                 to amend Crt's 10/15/99 Ord to expressly provide for

                 certification [186-1]. This Crt Ord ent 10/15/99, gr in part

                 and deny in part pltfs mot to dism and/or str, is expressly

                 amended to state that "Purs to 28 USC sect 1292(b), this Ord

                 involves controlling questions of law as to whi there is a

                 substantial grnd for difference of opinion, and an immediate

                 appeal from this Ord may materially advance the untimate

                 term of this litigation."  (ENT 7/21/99)  ntc (lk)

                 [Entry date 07/13/99] [Edit date 07/21/99]

 

7/9/99   214     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for Ord continuing hrg date  based upon

                 unavailabiolity of pltfs cnsl re mot to retax costs. Lodged

                 Prop Ord (lk) [Entry date 07/12/99]

 

7/9/99   216     ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts  denying exparte motion for Ord

                 continuing hrg date [214-1] (lk) [Entry date 07/13/99]

 

7/13/99  217     PROOF OF SERVICE by personal service  by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God on 7/9/99  of Prop ORd granting ex

                 parte appl for Ord cont hrg date based upon unavailabilty

                 of pltfs cnsl. (lk) [Entry date 07/14/99]

 

7/13/99  218     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 7/9/99 by pers svc of ex parte appl of pltf for Ord cont

                 hrg date based upon unavailability of pltfs cnsl; decl of

                 Sylvia P Lardiere in support. (lk) [Entry date 07/14/99]

 

7/15/99  219     EX PARTE REQUEST filed by defendant Philadelphia Church for

                 Crt to instruct the clerk to enter a "Separate Doc"

                 containing the Rule 54(B) jdm on pltfs cmp as prov in the

                 Crt Ord of 4/20/99. (lk) [Entry date 07/16/99]

                 [Edit date 07/16/99]

 

7/15/99  220     DECLARATION  of Mark B Helm by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support re exparte reqyest for Crt to instruct

                 the clerk to enter a "Separate Doc" containing the Rule

                 54(B) jdm [219-1] (lk) [Entry date 07/16/99]

 

7/15/99  221     RESPONSE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  to to exparte

                 motion for Crt to instruct the clerk to enter a "Separate

                 Doc" containing the Rule 54(B) jdm [219-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 07/16/99]

 

7/16/99  222     REPLY memo by defendant Philadelphia Church in support of

                 exparte motion for Crt to instruct the clerk to enter a

                 "Separate Doc" containing the Rule 54(B) jdm [219-1] (lk)

                 [Entry date 07/19/99]

 

7/16/99  223     PROOF OF SERVICE by pers svc by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God on 7/15/99  of resp to dfts ex parte req for Crt to

                 instruct, etc. (lk) [Entry date 07/19/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 24  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

7/21/99  224     JUDGMENT ON COMPLAINT: by Judge J. S. Letts. Judgment is

                 hereby ent under FRCP 54(b) in favor of dft Philadelphia

                 Church of God on plaintiff Worldwide Church of God's cmp

                 herein, and pltf shall take nothing by way of its cmp. This

                 matter will be considered upon renewed motion in September

                 or later . (ENT 7/23/99) (lk) [Entry date 07/23/99]

 

7/27/99  225     MINUTES:  Case should have been closed on entry dated

                 7/21/99  terminating case (MD JS-6) by Judge J. S. Letts

                 CR: none  (ENT 7/29/99) (lk) [Entry date 07/29/99]

 

7/29/99  226     NOTICE by defendant Philadelphia Church of Entry of Ord gr

                 dfts ex parte appl to amd crt Oct 15, 1997 Ord to expressly

                 provide for certification under 28 USC sect 1292(b). (lk)

                 [Entry date 07/29/99]

 

7/29/99  227     NOTICE by defendant Philadelphia Church of entry of

                 judgment on complaint. (lk) [Entry date 07/29/99]

 

7/30/99  --      REPORT ON THE DETERMINATION OF AN ACTION REGARDING

                 COPYRIGHT (cc: form mailed to Washington, D.C.)(Closing) (vf)

                 [Entry date 07/30/99]

 

8/19/99  229     NOTICE of Special Master's Ord Unsealing & Lifting

                 Confidentiality restrictions frm pleadings on cross-motions

                 for summary adj or partial S/J by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church (ca) [Entry date 08/24/99]

 

8/19/99  230     ORDER by Judge Eli Chernow, Special Master Appointed by J.

                 S. Letts granting notice of Special Master's Order unsealing

                 & lifting confidentiality restrictions frm pleadings on

                 cross-motions for summary adj & S/J [229-1].  The Clk of Crt

                 shall unseal the following documents: Memo PA's in suppt of

                 dft Philadelphia Church of God, Inc.'s Motion for Summary

                 Adj fld 1/11/99; Memo PA's of pltf Worldwide Church of God

                 in oppos to dft's motn for Summary Adj, fld 1/23/99; reply

                 memo in suppt of dfts Philadelphia Church of God, Inc.'s

                 motn for summary adj, filed 2/1/99; Ntc of motn & motn of

                 pltf Worldwide Church of God for partial S/J fld 1/11/99;

                 Memo PA's in oppos to pltf Worlwide Church of God's Motn for

                 Partial S/J, filed 1/25/99; and pltfs reply memo of PA's in

                 suppt of motn for partial S/J, filed 2/1/99 (ca)

                 [Entry date 08/24/99] [Edit date 08/25/99]

 

8/23/99  228     NOTICE OF APPEAL by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  to 9th

                 C/A from Dist. Court jgm fld 7/21/99, ent 7/23/99, ord fld

                 5/28/99, ord fld 4/15/99, ent 4/20/99 [224-1], [178-1],

                 [0-0] (cc: Sylvia Lardiere, Browne & Woods; Munger, Tolles

                 & Olson, Los Angeles,; Munger, Tolles & Olson, San

                 Francisco )  Fee: Paid (fvap) [Entry date 08/23/99]

 

8/31/99  231     DECLARATIONS of RALPH K HELGE & BENJAMIN D SCHEIBE by

                 plaintiff Worldwide Church God (jag) [Entry date 09/01/99]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 25  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

8/31/99  232     SECOND SUPPL OPPOSITION by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 to mot for atty's fees (jag) [Entry date 09/02/99]

 

9/13/99  233     SUPPLEMENTAL REPLY MEMORANDUM by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in suppt of motion for attorney fees [153-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 09/14/99]

 

9/22/99  234     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 2/18/97, 11/25/97, 1/5/98 re  transcript [195-1], re

                 transcript [184-1], 7/12/99;   CR: Terry Kramer (fvap)

                 [Entry date 09/23/99]

 

9/23/99  235     NOTIFICATION by Circuit Court of Appellate Docket Number

                 appeal [228-1] 99-56489 (wdc) [Entry date 09/23/99]

 

9/23/99  236     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 7/12/99 (Re: [228-1], [189-1], [168-1])  CR: Terry

                 Kramer (pjap) [Entry date 09/28/99]

 

9/23/99  --      TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 7/12/99 (pjap)

                 [Entry date 09/28/99]

 

9/28/99  237     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God requesting Nov hrg on dft's mot for attys fees; Decl

                 of Allan Browne & Sylvia P. Lardiere in suppt; Lodged

                 propsd ord (jp) [Entry date 09/29/99]

 

10/1/99  238     STATEMENT by defendant Philadelphia Church in resp to ex

                 parte appl for requesting Nov hrg date on dft's mot for

                 attys fees [237-1] (jp) [Entry date 10/04/99]

 

10/4/99  239     ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts  granting  exparte motion

                 requesting Nov hrg on dft's mot for attys fees shall be

                 heard on 11/15/99 at 1:00 pm [237-1] (bg)

                 [Entry date 10/06/99]

 

11/12/99 --      CLERK'S record on appeal transmitted to Circuit   vols: 15

                 transcripts: 3, 4 voluminous folders and 1 under seal doc

                 (dl) [Entry date 11/12/99]

 

11/15/99 241     MINUTES by Judge J. S. Letts:  The Crt GRANTED the exparte

                 application for attorneys fees; Cnst make stmts to the Crt

                 CR: Terry Kramer (jp) [Entry date 11/30/99]

 

11/19/99 240     ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts; It is ordered that dft

                 Philadelphia Church of God's motion for attorney fees

                 [153-1] is GRANTED in the amt of $289,685. Plf's motion to

                 retax costs [174-1] is DENIED. (jag) [Entry date 11/22/99]

 

11/30/99 242     NOTICE OF APPEAL by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  to 9th

                 C/A from Dist. Court ord fld 11/19/99 [240-1]  (cc: Sylvia

                 P. Lardiere, Browne & Woods; Muinger, Tolles & Olson, San

                 Francisco, CA; Munger, Tolles & Olson, Los Angeles, CA )

                 Fee: Paid. (fvap) [Entry date 11/30/99]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 26  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

11/30/99 243     REPRESENTATION STATEMENT re appeal [242-1] (fvap)

                 [Entry date 11/30/99]

 

12/9/99  244     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 to amend Crt's 11/22/99 ord GR dft's mot for attys fees &

                 DEN plf's mot to re-tax costs, and to enter judgment on

                 the award of fees & costs; Lodged propsd ord & propsd jgm

                 (jp) [Entry date 12/10/99]

 

12/9/99  245     DECLARATION of Mark B. Helm by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in suppt of exparte appl to amend Crt's 11/22/99 ord

                 GR dft's mot for attys fees & DEN plf's mot to re-tax costs

                 [244-1], to enter judgment on the award of fees & costs

                 [244-2] (jp) [Entry date 12/10/99]

 

12/9/99  246     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church on

                 12/9/99 of exparte appl; Decl of Mark B. Helm; propsd jgm;

                 propsd ord (jp) [Entry date 12/10/99]

 

12/9/99  247     TRANSCRIPT DESIGNATION and ordering form for dates:

                 2/18/97, 11/25/97, 1/5/98, 4/17/98, 2/8/99, 7/12/99,

                 11/15/99  CR: Terry Kramer (pjap) [Entry date 12/13/99]

 

12/13/99 248     RESPONSE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to exparte

                 motion to amend Crt's 11/22/99 ord GR dft's mot for attys

                 fees & DEN plf's mot to re-tax costs [244-1], to enter

                 judgment on the award of fees & costs [244-2], Objection of

                 plf to findings of fact, conclusions of law, & form of ord

                 propsd by dft; Request for stay; Decl of Sylvia P. Lardiere

                 (jp) [Entry date 12/14/99]

 

12/13/99 248     REQUEST by plaintiff Worldwide Church God for stay; Decl of

                 Sylvia P. Lardiere; Lodged propsd ord (jp)

                 [Entry date 12/14/99]

 

12/14/99 249     JUDGMENT: It is hereby ORD that dft Philadelphia Church of

                 God Inc is awarded $289,685.00 in attys fees against

                 Worldwide Church of God's cmp & taht dft is fur awarded its

                 costs in the amt of $6,166.90. by Judge J. S. Letts . (ENT

                 12/15/99), send copies & ntc (pj) [Entry date 12/15/99]

 

12/14/99 250     ORDER  by Judge J. S. Letts  that dfts mot for atty fees is

                 GRANTED in the amt of $289,685.00.  Pltfs mot ot re-tax

                 costs is DENIED, and dft is entitled to recover its cost in

                 the amt of $6,166.90; granting exparte motion to amend

                 Crt's 11/22/99 ord GR dft's mot for attys fees & DEN plf's

                 mot to re-tax costs [244-1], granting  exparte motion to

                 enter judgment on the award of fees & costs [244-2]. (ENT

                 12/15/99)  ntc. (lk) [Entry date 12/15/99]

 

12/15/99 258     ORDER Denying propsd ord staying attys' fee jgm pending

                 disposition of pla's appeals by Judge J. S. Letts (bp)

                 [Entry date 01/13/00]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 27  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

12/16/99 251     REPLY by defendant Philadelphia Church in suppt of exparte

                 appl to amend Crt's 11/22/99 ord GR dft's mot for attys

                 fees & DEN plf's mot to re-tax costs [244-1], to enter

                 judgment on the award of fees & costs [244-2]; Lodged

                 propsd ord (jp) [Entry date 12/17/99]

 

12/20/99 252     NOTICE of entry of jgm awarding dft Phily Church attyfees

                 by defendant Philadelphia Church (bp) [Entry date 12/21/99]

 

12/20/99 253     NOTICE of entry of ord granting ex parte appl to amd crt's

                 11/22/99 ord; mot for attyfees by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church (bp) [Entry date 12/21/99]

 

12/20/99 254     REVISED JUDGMENT AND ORDER by Judge J. S. Letts:  Deft

                 Philadelphia Church of God Inc awarded $289,685.00 in atty

                 fees agst plf Worldwide Church of God and deft fur awarded

                 its costs of $6,166.90; execution of this jdmt is STAYED

                 until 10 days following disposition by USCA of plf

                 consolidated appreal frm this crt 4/20/99 ord and jdmt ent

                 7/23/99 [248-1] (ENT 12/22/99) scan/ntcs (lc)

                 [Entry date 12/22/99]

 

1/3/00   257     STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge J. S. Letts re execution of

                 judgment (jp) [Entry date 01/10/00]

 

1/5/00   255     NOTIFICATION by Circuit Court of Appellate Docket Number

                 appeal [242-1] 99-56978 (ghap) [Entry date 01/05/00]

 

1/7/00   256     NOTICE OF APPEAL by plaintiff Worldwide Church of God to

                 9th C/A from Dist. Court Jgm fld 12/14/99 & ent 12/15/99

                 [249-1] (cc: Sylvia P. Lardiere, Browne & Woods LLP; Ralph

                 K. Helge; Mark B. Helm, Munger, Tolles & Olson; Kelly

                 Klaus, Munger, Tolles & Olson LLP) Fee: Paid. (pjap)

                 [Entry date 01/10/00]

 

2/4/00   259     NOTIFICATION by Circuit Court of Appellate Docket Number

                 appeal [256-1] 00-55174 (dl) [Entry date 02/04/00]

 

6/6/00   260     9th cca ord applnt's mot for a cont stay od prceeding is

                 GR.  These apps are stayed until 7/13/00.  (CA# 99-56978 &

                 00-55174) (ghap) [Entry date 06/14/00]

 

11/15/00 261     9thcca Order: The appellant's motn for a continued stay of

                 proceedings is gr. (weap) [Entry date 11/20/00]

 

11/20/00 272     RECORD on appeal returned from U.S. Court of Appeals re

                 appeal [256-1], re  appeal [242-1]   vols: 15 ,exhibits: 1

                 brown folder of underseal doc's #120,transcripts: 3 &  4

                 brown folder of doc's # 94,105,119 & 231. (ghap)

                 [Entry date 01/12/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 28  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

12/4/00  262     NOTICE OF DISCREPANCY AND ORDER by Judge J. S. Letts; IT IS

                 HEREBY ORD the Bill of Costs is NOT to be fld, but instead

                 REJECTED, & is ORD rtn to Cnsl (Missing ntc of appl to tax

                 costs) (jp) [Entry date 12/05/00]

 

12/5/00  265     NOTICE OF APPLICATION TO TAX COSTS submitted by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God; bill of cost hearing set on 10:00

                 12/20/00 (jp) [Entry date 12/12/00]

 

12/8/00  263     CERTIFIED COPY of Appellate Court Order: Appeals #99-55850,

                 99-55934, 99-56489, REVERSE the Decision of the District

                 Court [Appeal [228-1], [Appeal [189-1], [Appeal [168-1];

                 DISMISS the appeal from the denial of Worlwide Church of

                 God's motion for injunction pending Appeal #99-56005 as

                 moot, and REMAND for entry of a P/I pending a trial of any

                 damages & final adjudication. (MD JS-5) ENT: 12/12/00 (NTC

                 SENT) (jp) [Entry date 12/12/00]

 

12/8/00  264     NOTICE OF DOCUMENT DISCREPANCY APPROVED by Manager Richard

                 Janisch the Plf's Notice of Appl to tax costs is to be fld

                 & proc. The filing date is ORD to be the date the doc was

                 stamped "rcvd but not fld on 12/5/00) w/the Clk. (jp)

                 [Entry date 12/12/00]

 

12/8/00  266     MANDATE from Circuit Court of Appeals: Appeals #99-55850,

                 99-55934, 99-56005, 99-56489 REVERSING, DISMISS, and

                 REMANDING; The record reflects that costs of the prevailing

                 pty were taxed by the 9th CCA in the amount of $2,684.35 on

                 11/17/00; The Crt set the trial re damages on cal 2/6/01 @

                 9:00 (send) (jp) [Entry date 12/12/00]

 

12/15/00 267     REQUEST by defendant Philadelphia Church of God Inc   for

                 status conference (bg) [Entry date 12/18/00]

 

12/20/00 --      COSTS taxed for plaintiff Worldwide Church God in the

                 amount of $ 510.75 against defendant Philadelphia Church;

                 bill of cost hearing held (jp) [Entry date 12/26/00]

 

12/21/00 268     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 for preliminary injunction purs to opinion of 9th circuit;

                 Decl of Benjamin D. Scheibe (jp) (seal)

                 [Entry date 12/27/00] [Edit date 12/29/00]

 

12/22/00 270     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to plf's

                 exparte appl for preliminary injunction purs to opinion of

                 9th circuit [268-1] (jp) [Entry date 12/29/00]

 

12/28/00 269     REPLY MEMORANDUM by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in suppt

                 of exparte appl for preliminary injunction purs to opinion

                 of 9th circuit [268-1] (jp) [Entry date 12/29/00]

 

1/4/01   271     RESPONSE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to request for

                 status conference [267-1] (seal) [Entry date 01/05/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 29  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

1/19/01  273     ORDER OF THE CHIEF JUDGE # 01-021 approved  by Judge Terry

                 J. Hatter this case is transferred from the calendar  of

                 Judge J. S. Letts  to the calendar  of Judge Christina A.

                 Snyder for all further proceedings. The new case number

                 will now read as CV 97-5306 CAS (CWx)  (cc: all counsel) (rn)

                 [Entry date 01/24/01]

 

1/29/01  274     MINUTES:  Telephonic staus conf was held. The crt sets a

                 fur status conf on the iss of the pending prelim inj  on

                 2/7/01 12pm. Pending hrg on 2/7/01  by Judge Christina A.

                 Snyder CR: Laura Elias (P Send) (pj) [Entry date 02/09/01]

 

2/7/01   275     MINUTES: STATUS CONF RE PRELIM INJ: Cnsl for plf is ord

                 submita pop prel inj with terms stated on the record. The

                 trl date of 2/6/01 is vacated. A fur status conf is set;

                 status conf set on 12:00 6/28/01 by Judge Christina A.

                 Snyder  CR: Laura Elias (P Send) (pj) [Entry date 02/09/01]

 

2/14/01  276     OBJS to plf's propsd form by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 to exparte motion for preliminary injunction purs to

                 opinion of 9th circuit [268-1]; lodged prop prelim

                 injunction (el) [Entry date 02/15/01]

 

2/23/01  277     RESPONSE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to Philadelphia

                 Church of God's objs to exparte motion for preliminary

                 injunction purs to opinion of 9th circuit [268-1] (el)

                 [Entry date 02/26/01]

 

2/26/01  278     REPLY by defendant Philadelphia Church re propsd form of

                 injunction (el) [Entry date 02/27/01]

 

2/27/01  279     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 2/7/01 (Re: )  CR: Laura Elias (weap)

                 [Entry date 02/28/01]

 

2/27/01  --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 2/7/01 (weap)

                 [Entry date 02/28/01]

 

3/2/01   280     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 3/2/01  of ntc of mot & mot to amd ans & cntclm & other

                 supporting docs (pj) [Entry date 03/05/01]

 

3/2/01   281     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God, counter-claimant Philadelphia Church to amend ans &

                 cntclm ; motion hearing set for 10:00 3/26/01 Lodged ord (pj)

                 [Entry date 03/05/01]

 

3/2/01   282     MEMORANDUM of P&A IN SUPPORT by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church, counter-claimant Philadelphia Church,

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church  of motion to amend

                 ans & cntclm [281-1] (pj) [Entry date 03/05/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 30  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

3/2/01   283     DECLARATION  of MARK B HELM IN SUPPT by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church, counter-claimant Philadelphia Church,

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church re motion to amend ans

                 & cntclm [281-1] (pj) [Entry date 03/05/01]

 

3/7/01   284     PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION  by Judge Christina A. Snyder that

                 during the pendency of this actn, dft Philadelphia Church

                 of God, its officers, agents, etc are enjoined and

                 restrained from engaging in committing or performing di or

                 indi acts and FUR ORD to deliver, etc (see doc for details);

                  the Crt reserves jurisd to modify this injunction a the

                 end of justice may require (ENT 3/07/2001) send/ntcd (el)

                 [Entry date 03/07/01]

 

3/9/01   285     STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder that the

                 hearing on PCG's motion to amend ans & cntclm [281-1] is

                 contd to 10:00 4/16/01; PCG's reply due on or bfr 4/4/01;

                 WCG's oppo due on or bfr 3/19/01 and hearing on WCG's

                 exparte motion for preliminary injunction purs to opinion

                 of 9th circuit [268-1] will be hld on 10:00 4/16/01; oppo

                 due on or bfr 3/28/01 and reply due on or bfr 4/9/01 (el)

                 [Entry date 03/12/01]

 

3/13/01  286     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for judgment on the pleadings, or alt for summary

                 judgment ; motion hearing set for 10:00 4/16/01   Lodged

                 prop stmt & ord (el) [Entry date 03/14/01]

 

3/13/01  287     REQUEST by plaintiff Worldwide Church God for judicial

                 notice re motion for judgment on the pleadings [286-1], re

                 motion for summary judgment [286-2] (el)

                 [Entry date 03/14/01]

 

3/13/01  288     EVIDENCE APPENDIX in suppt by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to motion for judgment on the pleadings [286-1], motion

                 for summary judgment [286-2] (el) [Entry date 03/14/01]

 

3/13/01  320     NOTICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God of doc withheld

                 from case file (el) [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

3/14/01  289     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 3/13/01 of Mtn for jgm on the pldgs or in the alt for sum

                 jgm and rel docs srvd on Mark B HeimEsq by personal svc (el)

                 [Entry date 03/15/01]

 

3/14/01  --      9th cca jgm frm dist crt hereby is rev.  (FWD TO

                 CRD)(99-56978,00-55174) (ghap) [Entry date 03/21/01]

 

3/15/01  290     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by Philadelphia Church to

                 continue mtn for jgm on the pldgs and/or sum jgm; Mem of

                 PA; Decl of Kelly M Klaus; Lodged Prop ord (el)

                 [Entry date 03/19/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 31  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

3/19/01  291     OPPOSITION by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to dft's

                 motion to amend ans & cntclm [281-1] (el)

                 [Entry date 03/20/01]

 

3/19/01  292     DECLARATION of Benjamin D Scheibe in oppo by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God re dft's motion to amend ans & cntclm

                 (el) [Entry date 03/20/01]

 

3/20/01  293     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 3/19/01 of oppo to mtn to amd & decl in oppo srvd on Mark B

                 Helm Esq by personal service (el) [Entry date 03/21/01]

 

3/20/01  295     MEMORANDUM of P&A filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 in opposition to PCG's exparte motion to continue mtn for

                 jgm on the pldgs and/or sum jgm [290-1] (el)

                 [Entry date 03/28/01]

 

3/22/01  294     MINUTES:  by Judge Dhristina A. Snyder. taking motion for

                 judgment on the pleadings [286-1] off calendar, taking

                 motion for summary judgment [286-2] off calendar, taking

                 motion to amend ans & cntclm [281-1] off calendar CR: Not

                 Present      (SND) (yc) [Entry date 03/26/01]

 

4/2/01   298     RENEWED NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God for judgment on the pleadings, or alt for

                 summary judgment ; motion hearing set for 10:00 4/23/01 (el)

                 [Entry date 04/04/01]

 

4/3/01   296     STIPULATION and ORDER  by Judge Christina A. Snyder that

                 the EVIDENCE APPENDIX fld by plf on 3/13/2001 will be

                 placed UNDER SEAL by the Crt, and plf's cnsl shl deliver to

                 the Clerk's Office appropriate cover sheets for the Evid

                 Appendix pur to Protective Order (el) [Entry date 04/03/01]

 

4/3/01   297     REQUEST by defendant Philadelphia Church for Status

                 Conference (el) [Entry date 04/03/01]

 

4/3/01   299     MINUTES: ORDER setting ; mandatory status conference set

                 on 11:30 4/9/01; cnsl shd be present in crt   by Judge

                 Christina A. Snyder  CR: None Present (el)

                 [Entry date 04/04/01]

 

4/3/01   300     JOINT STATUS REPORT Concerning Petition for writ of

                 certiorari (jp) [Entry date 04/05/01]

 

4/6/01   301     STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God (bp) [Entry date 04/09/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 32  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

4/9/01   302     MINUTES: Prcdgs ; mandatory status conference held Cnsl

                 req tht the stay be lifted and mots go forward; Crt grants

                 req and the stay ordered lifted; granting exparte motion to

                 continue mot for jgm on the pldgs and/or sum jgm [290-1].

                 The hearing on motion to amend ans & cntclm [281-1] or alt

                 motion for judgment on pleadings [298-1] and hearing on

                 motion for summary judgment [298-2] are set for 10:00

                 5/7/01. Plf shl re-ntc the mots; opp due 4/17/01; reply if

                 any due 4/30/01; cnsl may go to Mag Judge Woehrle for

                 discov purposes.  IT IS SO ORDERED by Judge Christina A.

                 Snyder CR: Noreen Cerge (el) [Entry date 04/12/01]

 

4/17/01  303     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion for

                 judgment on the pleadings [298-1], motion for summary

                 judgment [298-2] (el) [Entry date 04/18/01]

 

4/17/01  304     EVID OBJS to Materials submitted in suppt by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church to plf's motion for judgment on the

                 pleadings [298-1], motion for summary judgment [298-2] (el)

                 [Entry date 04/18/01]

 

4/17/01  305     DECLARATION of Mark B Helm in suppt by dft Philadelphia

                 Church's opp to motion for judgment on the pleadings

                 [298-1], motion for summary judgment [298-2] (el)

                 [Entry date 04/18/01]

 

4/17/01  306     STATEMENT Gen Iss of Material Fact in opp by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church  re motion for judgment on the

                 pleadings [298-1], motion for summary judgment [298-2] (el)

                 [Entry date 04/18/01]

 

4/17/01  307     REQUEST by defendant Philadelphia Church for judicial

                 notice in suppt of opp re motion for judgment on the

                 pleadings [298-1], re motion for summary judgment [298-2]

                 (el) [Entry date 04/18/01]

 

4/17/01  308     REQUEST by defendant Philadelphia Church for DENIAL or in

                 the alt, continuance of plf Worldwide Church of God's mot

                 for jgm on the pldgs and/or summ jgm purs to FRCP 56(f);

                 Decl of Kelly M Klaus in suppt (el) [Entry date 04/18/01]

 

4/17/01  310     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church on

                 4/17/01 of Opp to plf's mot for jgm on the pldgs and/or

                 summ jgm and rel docs srvd on Benjamin D Scheibe Esq by

                 personal svc (el) [Entry date 04/18/01]

 

4/17/01  319     MAIL Returned [299-1], [299-2] addressed to defendant

                 Philadelphia Church; terminating atty Kwani T Mumina (el)

                 [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

4/20/01  311     CERTIFIED COPY of Appellate Court Order: No. 99-56978,

                 reversing decision of the District Court [Appeal [242-1];

                 No. 00-55174, reversing decision of the District Court

                 [Appeal [256-1] (ENT 4/24/2001) send/mld cpys (el)


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 33  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                 [Entry date 04/24/01] [Edit date 04/24/01]

 

4/20/01  312     CRT ORDERS MANDATE from Circuit Court of Appeals reversing

                 is hereby filed and spread upon the mins of this Crt (send)

                 mailed cpys (el) [Entry date 04/24/01]

                 [Edit date 04/24/01]

 

4/30/01  313     REPLY BRIEF in suppt by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to

                 its motion for judgment on the pleadings [298-1], motion

                 for summary judgment [298-2] (el) [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

4/30/01  314     SUPPL DECLARATION of Benjamin D Scheibe and Ralph K Helge

                 by plaintiff Worldwide Church God re motion for judgment on

                 the [298-1], motion for summary judgment [298-2] (el)

                 [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

4/30/01  315     SUPPL REQUEST by plaintiff Worldwide Church God for

                 judicial notice in suppt re motion for judgment on the

                 pleadings [298-1], re motion for summary judgment [298-2]

                 (el) [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

4/30/01  316     REPLY by defendant Philadelphia Church in suppt of motion

                 to amend ans & cntclm [281-1] (el) [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

4/30/01  317     DECLARATION of Kelly M Klaus in suppt by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church re motion to amend ans & cntclm [281-1]

                 (el) [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

4/30/01  321     MINUTES before Judge Christina A. Snyder: Plf's motion for

                 Jgm on the pldgs [298-1] and/or summary judgment [298-2] is

                 hereby CONT to 10:00 on 8/13/01. CR: None (Psend) (jp)

                 [Entry date 05/03/01]

 

5/1/01   318     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 4/30/01 of reply brief in suppt of its mot for jgm on the

                 pldgs or alt summ jgm and rel docs srvd on Mark B Helm Esq

                 by personal svc (el) [Entry date 05/02/01]

 

5/4/01   322     EVIDENTIARY OBJS to materials submitted by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church to motion for judgment on the pleadings

                 [298-1], motion for summary judgment [298-2] (el)

                 [Entry date 05/07/01]

 

5/7/01   323     MINUTES: ORDER by Judge Christina A Snyder the PCG's motion

                 for leave to amend the counterclaim is GRANTED with regard

                 to the non-MOA works. The motion is otherwise DENIED.  CR:

                 Laura Elias (Send) (el) [Entry date 05/09/01]

                 [Edit date 05/09/01]

 

5/15/01  324     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date: 4/9/01 CR: Noreen Cerge. (wdc) [Entry date 05/16/01]

 

5/15/01  --      TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 4/9/01. (wdc)

                 [Entry date 05/16/01]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 34  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

5/18/01  325     AMENDED ANSWER  [45-1] by defendant Philadelphia Church for

                 all fur proceedings authorized by statute, local rules and

                 general orders. AND (pj) [Entry date 05/21/01]

 

5/18/01  325     AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM [45-2] by counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church (pj) [Entry date 05/21/01]

 

5/30/01  326     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 5/7/01  CR: Laura Elias (dl) [Entry date 06/01/01]

 

5/30/01  --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 5/7/01 (dl)

                 [Entry date 06/01/01]

 

6/13/01  327     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to dismiss, and/or to strike purs to rules 12(b)(6)

                 and 12(f) ; motion hearing set for 10:00 7/9/01 Lodged

                 order (pj) [Entry date 06/14/01]

 

6/25/01  328     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to Plf

                 Worldwide Church of God's motion to dismiss [327-1], &/or

                 strike [327-2] (ir) [Entry date 06/25/01]

 

6/26/01  329     MINUTES:  Status conference is hereby cont to 10:00

                 7/9/01 by Judge Christina A. Snyder CR: None Present (pj)

                 [Entry date 06/27/01]

 

6/26/01  330     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church to compel production of documents; motion hearing

                 set for 10:00 7/10/01 (jp) [Entry date 06/29/01]

 

6/26/01  331     JOINT STIPULATION on motion to compel plf Worldwide Church

                 of God to produce documents [330-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 06/29/01]

 

7/2/01   332     SUPPL MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church of motion to compel production of documents [330-1];

                 Decl of Kelly M Klaus (el) [Entry date 07/03/01]

 

7/2/01   333     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in suppt of

                 motion to dismiss [327-1], &/or strike purs to Rules

                 12(b)(6) and 12(f) [327-2] (ir) [Entry date 07/09/01]

 

7/3/01   334     SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in opposition to Philadelphia Church of God Inc's

                 motion to compel production of documents [330-1] (ir)

                 [Entry date 07/09/01]

 

7/6/01   335     MINUTES: (IN CHAMBERS) by Discovery Carla M. Woehrle;

                 resetting hearing on motion to compel production of

                 documents [330-1] 10:00 7/24/01  CR: N/A      P SND (yc)

                 [Entry date 07/09/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 35  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

7/9/01   340     MINUTES: Plf's motion to dismiss [327-1] and motion to

                 strike purs to rules 12(b)(6) and 12(f) [327-2] were argued

                 and taken under submission.  Cnsl to file fur briefs: Plf

                 by 7/16/01; dfts respond by 7/18/01; cnsl shl serve ea

                 other via fax; status conf is cont to 9/10/01 IT IS SO

                 ORDERED by Judge Christina A. Snyder CR: Laura Elias (el)

                 [Entry date 07/23/01]

 

7/9/01   341     MINUTES: ORDER that hearing on plf's motion for judgment on

                 the pleadings [298-1], and hearing on motion for summary

                 judgment [298-2] is continued to 10:00 9/10/01 by Judge

                 Christina A. Snyder  CR: none present (el)

                 [Entry date 07/23/01]

 

7/16/01  336     SUPPL BRIEF by plaintiff Worldwide Church God re:

                 governmental brief in suppt of motion to dismiss [327-1],

                 motion to strike purs to rules 12(b)(6) 12(f) [327-2] (el)

                 [Entry date 07/18/01]

 

7/16/01  337     SUPPL BRIEF IN OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 to motion to dismiss [327-1], motion to strike purs to

                 rules 12(b)(6) 12(f) [327-2] (el) [Entry date 07/18/01]

 

7/18/01  338     REPLY BRIEF by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to ladelphia

                 Church of God's suppl brief in suppt of motion to dismiss

                 [327-1], motion to strike purs to rules 12(b)(6) and 12(f)

                 [327-2] (el) [Entry date 07/19/01]

 

7/18/01  339     REPLY by defendant Philadelphia Church of God Inc to plf

                 Worldwide Church of God's "suppl brief re governmental

                 actn" (el) [Entry date 07/19/01]

 

7/20/01  342     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 7/9/01 (Re: )  CR: Laura Elias (pjap)

                 [Entry date 07/24/01]

 

7/20/01  --      TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 7/9/01 (pjap)

                 [Entry date 07/24/01]

 

7/24/01  343     MINUTES: Dft's motion to compel production of documents

                 [330-1] is GRANTED IN PART & DENIED IN PART (See doc for

                 specifics); All docs ord produced are to be produced w/in

                 15 days of this date by Discovery Carla M. Woehrle CR:

                 01-37/01-38 (SEND) (ir) [Entry date 07/25/01]

 

8/27/01  345     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for judgment on the pleadings, or alt for summary

                 judgment; motion hearing set for 10:00 9/24/01 (ir)

                 [Entry date 08/31/01]

 

8/27/01  346     SEPARATE STATEMENT of Uncontroverted Facts & Conclusions of

                 law by plaintiff Worldwide Church God re motion for

                 judgment on the pleadings [345-1], or alt summary judgment

                 [345-2] (ir) [Entry date 08/31/01]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 36  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

8/27/01  347     REQUEST by plaintiff Worldwide Church God for Judicial

                 Notice in suppt of its motion for judgment on the pleadings

                 [345-1], or alt for summary judgment [345-2] (ir)

                 [Entry date 08/31/01]

 

8/27/01  348     NOTICE OF DOCUEMENT W/HELD FROM CASE by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God (ir) [Entry date 08/31/01]

 

8/27/01  349     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 8/27/01 of Plf Worldwide Church of God's Ntc of mot & mot

                 for jgm on the pldgs or alt for summary jgm (See doc for

                 fur details) (ir) [Entry date 08/31/01]

 

8/30/01  344     NOTICE OF DISCREPANCY AND ORDER by Judge Christina A.

                 Snyder IT IS HEREBY ORD: The Ntc Mot summary jgm; Separate

                 Stmt of Uncontroverted facts; Req; Appendix; Proof of Svc

                 are to be filed & processed. The filing date is ORD to be

                 the date the doc was stamped "rcd but not fld" w/Clk; rcd

                 date 8/27 (SEND) (ir) [Entry date 08/31/01]

 

9/4/01   350     Suppl OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion

                 for judgment on the pleadings [345-1], motion for summary

                 judgment [345-2] (tw) [Entry date 09/05/01]

 

9/4/01   351     STATEMENT of genuine issues of material fact by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church in opp to plfs  motion for judgment on

                 the pleadings [345-1], motion for summary judgment [345-2]

                 (tw) [Entry date 09/05/01]

 

9/4/01   352     EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS by defendant Philadelphia Church  to

                 materials submitted in suppt of motion for judgment on the

                 pleadings [345-1],  motion for summary judgment [345-2] (tw)

                 [Entry date 09/05/01]

 

9/4/01   353     REQUEST by defendant Philadelphia Church  for Judicial

                 Notice in suppt of  motion for judgment on the pleadings

                 [345-1], motion for summary judgment [345-2] (tw)

                 [Entry date 09/05/01]

 

9/4/01   354     NOTICE of under seal by defendant Philadelphia Church (tw)

                 [Entry date 09/05/01]

 

9/4/01   355     NOTICE of under seal by defendant Philadelphia Church (tw)

                 [Entry date 09/05/01]

 

9/13/01  356     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in suppt of

                 its' to motion for judgment on the pleadings [345-1], or

                 alt summary judgment [345-2] (ir) [Entry date 09/17/01]

 

9/13/01  357     EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to material submitted in opp to its motion for judgment

                 on the pleadings [345-1], or in the alt for summary

                 judgment [345-2] (ir) [Entry date 09/17/01]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 37  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

9/13/01  358     RESPONSE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to evidentiary

                 obj submitted by Counterclaimant Philadelphia Church of God

                 Inc re motion for judgment on the pleadings [345-1], or alt

                 summary judgment [345-2] (ir) [Entry date 09/17/01]

 

9/13/01  359     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 9/12/01 of Worldwide Church of God's reply brief in suppt

                 of its mot for jgm on the pldgs or alt summary jgm (See doc

                 for fur details) (ir) [Entry date 09/17/01]

 

9/19/01  360     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 7/24/01  CR: Dorothy Babykin (dl)

                 [Entry date 09/21/01]

 

9/19/01  --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 7/24/01 (dl)

                 [Entry date 09/21/01]

 

9/19/01  361     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by intervenor plaintiff Gary L

                 B Radshaw to intervene as a plf (pj) [Entry date 09/24/01]

 

9/24/01  363     MINUTES: Plf's motion for judgment on the pleadings [286-1]

                 or in the alt for summary judgment [286-2] (Fld 3/13/01) &

                 Plf's motion for judgment on the pleadings [345-1] or in

                 the alt for summary judgment [345-2] (Fld 8/27/01); Above

                 entitled mots were argued before Crt; The motions are taken

                 under submission; Crt will iss a propsd jgm for comment &

                 set hrg for fur argument on 11/5/01 @ 9:30 IT IS SO ORD by

                 Judge Christina A. Snyder CR: Laura Elias (SEND) (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/02/01]

 

9/28/01  362     MINUTES: Crt denies Bradshaw's motion to intervene as a plf

                 [361-1] IT IS SO ORD by Judge Christina A. Snyder (SEND) (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/01/01]

 

10/24/01 364     DECLARATION of Matthew Morgan by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God fld in suppt of its' motion for judgment on the

                 pleadings [345-1], or alt summary judgment [345-2] (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/25/01]

 

11/1/01  365     DECLARATION of Allan Browne by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God re motion for judgment on the pleadings [345-1],

                 summary judgment [345-2] & RFRA mot (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/01/01]

 

11/1/01  366     RESPONSE by defendant Philadelphia Church to declaration of

                 Matthew Morgan [364-1]; Decl of Mark B Helm (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/02/01]

 

11/1/01  367     PROOF OF PERSONAL SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 on 11/1/01 of Dft's response to decl of Mattew Morgan; Decl

                 of Mark B Helm (ir) [Entry date 11/02/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 38  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

11/6/01  369     MINUTES: Plf's motion for judgment on the pleadings

                 [286-1], or alt for summary judgment [286-2] (Fld 3/13/01)

                 & Plfs' motion for judgment on the pleadings [345-1], or

                 alt for judgment [345-2] (Fld 8/27/01); Status Conf re

                 setting trial sched; A tentative rulin was iss on 11/5/01;

                 Crt cont matter from 11/5/01 to 11/6/01 @ 9:30; Now on this

                 date, above entitled mot(s) were argued before Crt; Crt

                 took mot(s) under submission; Fur status conference set

                 for 1:00 12/3/01 to determine a trial sched; Cnsl lodge

                 w/Crt 5 books as follows: 1)Missing dimension is set, 2)

                 The Wonderful World Tomorrow, 3)Pagan Holidays or Gods Holy

                 Days, 4)Which day is the Christian Sabbath, 5)The

                 Incredible Human Potential IT IS SO ORD by Judge Christina

                 A. Snyder CR: Deborah Gackle (ir) [Entry date 11/13/01]

 

11/13/01 368     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 9/24/01 (Re:) CR: Laura Elias. (ghap)

                 [Entry date 11/13/01]

 

11/13/01 --      TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 9/24/01. (ghap)

                 [Entry date 11/13/01]

 

11/14/01 370     ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder Plf's motion to strike

                 Dft-Cntclmt's affirmative defenses based on RFRA, estoppel

                 & unclean hands [327-2] is GRANTED; Plf's motion to dismiss

                 Dft-Clmnt's 1st claim for declartory relief [327-1] is

                 DENIED w/out prej; Plf's motion for judgment on the

                 pleadings [345-1] is DENIED; Plf's motion for summary

                 judgment [345-2] w/re to Dft-Clmnt's 2nd & 3rd claims for

                 declaratory relief are DENIED w/out prej; Plf's mot for

                 summary jgm w/re to Dft-Clmnt's 4th claim for declaratory

                 relief is GRANTED (See doc for specifics)(ENT 11/15/01)

                 (SEND/NTC) (ir) [Entry date 11/15/01]

 

11/20/01 371     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 11/06/01. CR: Deborah Gackle. (cbr)

                 [Entry date 11/21/01]

 

11/20/01 --      TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 11/06/01. (cbr)

                 [Entry date 11/21/01]

 

12/3/01  372     MINUTES: STATUS CONFERENCE; Trial sched is set as

                 follows: Pretrial Conference set for 11:30 9/9/02; jury

                 trial set on 9:30 10/15/02; mot cut-off 7/15/02; As to

                 discovery cut-off, cnsl shall file a propsd stip; Crt rtn

                 to cnsl the books lodged on 11/6/01: Books rtn to cnsl: The

                 missing dimension is set, The Wonderful World Tomorrow,

                 Pagan Holidays or Gods Holy Days, Which Day is the

                 Christian Sabbath, The Incredible Human Potential IT IS SO

                 ORD by Judge Christina A. Snyder CR: Stephen Williams

                 (SEND) (ir) [Entry date 12/17/01]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 39  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

12/14/01 373     NOTICE OF DISCREPANCY AND ORDER by Judge Christina A.

                 Snyder IT IS HEREBY ORD: The mot to interven is NOT to be

                 fld, but instead REJECTED & is ORD rtn to cnsl; rcd date

                 12/6/01 (Local Rule 11-4.1, NO copy provided for judge &

                 FRCP 5(d), No proof of svc attached to doc) (ir)

                 [Entry date 12/18/01]

 

12/28/01 374     ANSWER TO AMENDED COUNTERCLAIM [325-1] by counter-defendant

                 Worldwide Church of God (ir) [Entry date 01/02/02]

 

3/20/02  375     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by intervenor plaintiff Gary L

                 Bradshaw to intervene as a plf amd & suppl (pj)

                 [Entry date 03/26/02]

 

6/17/02  376     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to continue trial; memo of PA; Decl(s) of Miles J

                 Feldman & Ralph K Helge (ir) [Entry date 06/18/02]

 

6/20/02  377     NOTICE OF ERRATA by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 correcting motion to continue trial [376-1] (ir)

                 [Entry date 06/21/02]

 

6/24/02  378     MEMORANDUM of PA filed by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 opposition to Plf's motion to continue trial [376-1]; Decl

                 of Kelly M Klaus in suppt thereof (ir) [Entry date 06/27/02]

 

7/1/02   379     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in suppt of

                 its' motion to continue trial [376-1] & (related deadlines);

                  Supplemental Decl of Miles J Feldman (ir)

                 [Entry date 07/03/02]

 

7/5/02   380     NOTICE OF DISCREPANCY AND ORDER by Judge Christina A.

                 Snyder ordering Certificate of svc submitted received on

                 7/1/02 is not to be fld but instead rejected; Denial based

                 on: Local Rule 11-3.8 Lacking name, address, phone number

                 in upper left corner & Orig & copy must be blue backed (ir)

                 [Entry date 07/08/02]

 

7/8/02   381     MINUTES:  granting   motion to continue trial [376-1]

                 discovery ddl set on 9/16/02; Final Pretrial Conference

                 set for 11:00 11/18/02 ; jury trial set on 9:30 12/3/02

                 Motion filing cut off 9/27/02 by Judge Christina A. Snyder

                 CR: Laura Ellis (bg) [Entry date 07/29/02]

 

8/7/02   382     CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE on 6/26/02 of Zondervan Publishing

                 House's Response to 3rd pty Subpoena & Certificate of Svc

                 (ir) [Entry date 08/09/02]

 

8/14/02  383     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 7/8/02 (Re: )  CR: Laura Elias (weap)

                 [Entry date 08/16/02]

 

8/14/02  --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 7/8/02 (weap)

                 [Entry date 08/16/02]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 40  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

9/30/02  384     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for summary judgment re PCG's 1st Claim for

                 Declaratory Relief (Religious Freedom Restoration Act);

                 motion hearing set for 10:00 11/4/02; Lodged Propsd Ord &

                 Lodged Stmt *****FILED UNDER SEAL***** (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/01/02]

 

9/30/02  385     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God for summary judgment re PCG's 2nd Claim for

                 Declaratory Relief (Fair Use); motion hearing set for

                 10:00 11/4/02; Lodged Propsd Ord & Lodged Stmt (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/01/02]

 

9/30/02  387     REQUEST by plaintiff Worldwide Church God for Judicial

                 Notice in suppt of its motions for summary judgment re

                 PCG's 2nd Claim for Declaratory Relief (Fair Use) [385-1],

                 & summary judgment re PCG's 1st Claim for Declaratory

                 Relief (Religious Freedom Restoration Act) [384-1] (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/01/02]

 

9/30/02  388     PROOF OF PERSONAL SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 on 9/27/02 of Plf Worldwide Church of God's Ntc of mot &

                 mot for summary jgm re PCG's 2nd Claim for Declaratory

                 Relief (Fair Use) (See doc for fur details) (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/01/02]

 

10/2/02  389     DECLARATION of Jose Villegas & Miles J Feldman by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God in suppt of motion for summary

                 judgment re PCG's 2nd Claim for Declaratory Relief (Fair

                 Use) [385-1], & re PCG's 1st Claim for Declaratory Relief

                 (Religious Freedom Restoration Act) [384-1] (nhac)

                 [Entry date 10/04/02]

 

10/11/02 390     Ntc of lodging of sbj works by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in suppt of  motion for summary judgment re PCG's 2nd

                 Claim for Declaratory Relief (Fair Use) [385-1],  motion

                 for summary judgment re PCG's 1st Claim for Declaratory

                 Relief (Religious Freedom Restoration Act) [384-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 10/16/02]

 

10/11/02 391     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 10/11/02  of Boos (see doc) (tw) [Entry date 10/16/02]

 

10/15/02 392     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church for leave to reopen limited discovery and an

                 order finding a subject matter waiver of the

                 attorney-client privilege; motion hearing set for 10:00

                 11/4/02; Lodged Propsd Ord (mch) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 41  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

10/15/02 393     DECLARATIONS of Andrew Locher; Roger Brandon; Eric Anderson;

                  Joel Hilliker and Robert Locher by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in suppt of motion for leave to reopen limited

                 discovery [392-1], motion an order finding a subject waiver

                 of the attorney-client privilege [392-2] (mch)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/15/02 394     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church on

                 10/14/02 of Dft's Notice of Motion & Mot for leave to

                 reopen limited discov and an Ord finding a subject mtr

                 waiver of the atty-client privilege (see doc for fur

                 details) (mch) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/15/02 395     DECLARATION of Kelly M Klaus by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in suppt of motion for leave to reopen limited

                 discovery [392-1], motion an order finding a subject matter

                 waiver the attorney-client privilege [392-2] (mch)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/15/02 396     MEMORANDUM OF P/A by defendant Philadelphia Church of in

                 suppt of motion for leave to reopen limited discovery

                 [392-1], motion an order finding a subject matter waiver of

                 the attorney-client privilege [392-2] (mch)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/15/02 397     DECLARATION of Dennis Leap by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 in suppt of motion for leave to reopen limited discovery

                 [392-1], motion an order finding a subject matter waiver of

                 the attorney-client privilege [392-2] (mch)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/18/02 398     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by defendant, counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church for leave to file a consolidated

                 opposition to plaintiff's motions for summary judgment on

                 first and second counterclaims for relief; Declaration of

                 Kelly M. Klaus (jp) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/18/02 399     REQUEST by defendant Philadelphia Church, counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church for Judicial Notice in support of

                 opposition to ex parte application for leave to file a

                 consolidated opposition to plaintiff's motions for summary

                 judgment on first and second counterclaims for relief

                 [398-1] (jp) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/18/02 400     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant, counter-claimant Philadelphia

                 Church on 10/18/02 of Ex parte application for leave to file

                 a consolicated opposition to plaintiff's motions for summary

                 judgment on first and second counterclaims for relief (see

                 document for further details) (jp) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/21/02 412     OPPOSITION by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to motion for

                 leave to reopen limited discovery [392-1], and order

                 finding a subject matter waiver of the attorney-client

                 privilege [392-2] (jp) [Entry date 10/24/02]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 42  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

10/22/02 401     ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder the ex parte application

                 for leave to file a consolidated opposition to plaintiff's

                 motions for summary judgment on first and second

                 counterclaims for relief [398-1] is GRANTEDS (jp)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 402     DECLARATION of MARK B. HELM by defendant, counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church in support of opposition to plaintiff's

                 ex parte application for leave to file a consolidated

                 opposition to plaintiff's motions for summary judgment on

                 first and second counterclaims for relief [398-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 403     DECLARATION of SEALY M. YATES by defendant,

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church in support of

                 opposition to plaintiff's ex parte application for leave to

                 file a consolidated opposition to plaintiff's motions for

                 summary judgment on first and second counterclaims for

                 relief [398-1] (jp) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 404     EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS TO MATERIALS SUBMITTED by defendant,

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church in support of

                 plaintiff's motions for summary judgment 2nd Claim [385-1],

                 for summary judgment 1st Claim Relief [384-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 405     DECLARATION of J. GORDON MELTON by defendant,

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church consolidated

                 opposition to plaintiff's motions for summary judgment on

                 first and second counterclaims for relief [398-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 406     CONSOLIDATED OPPOSITION by defendant, counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church to plaintiff's motions for summary

                 judgment on first [384-1] and 2nd counterclaims for relief

                 (jp) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 407     DECLARATION of BEN G. GILL by defendant, counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church in support of consolidated opposition

                 to plaintiff's motion for summary judgment re PCG's 1st

                 Claim for Declaratory Relief (Religious Freedom Restoration

                 Act) [384-1],  motion for summary judgment re PCG's 2nd

                 Claim for Declaratory Relief (Fair Use) [385-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 408     DECLARATION of GERALD FLURRY by defendant, counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church in support of consolidated opposition

                 to plaintiff's motions for summary judgment on 1st [384-1],

                 2nd counterclaims for Relief  [385-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 43  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

10/22/02 409     STATEMENT OF GENUINE ISSUES OF MATERIAL FACT by defendant

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church in opposition to

                 plaintiff's motion for summary judgment re PCG's 2nd Claim

                 for Declaratory Relief (Fair Use) [385-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 410     STATEMENT OF GENUINE ISSUES OF MATERIAL FACT by defendant

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church in opposition to

                 plaintiff's  motion for summary judgment re PCG's 1st Claim

                 for Declaratory Relief (Religious Freedom Restoration Act)

                 [384-1] (jp) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/22/02 411     DECLARATION  of KELLY M. KLAUS by defendant,

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church in support of

                 opposition to plaintiff's motion for summary judgment

                 [384-1], [385-1] (jp) [Entry date 10/23/02]

 

10/28/02 413     REPLY by defendant Philadelphia Church in support of motion

                 for leave to reopen limited discovery [392-1], motion an

                 order finding a subject matter waiver of the

                 attorney-client privilege [392-2] (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 414     SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF KELLY M. KLAUS by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church in support of motion for leave to

                 reopen limited discovery [392-1], re  motion an order

                 finding a subject matter waiver of the attorney-client

                 privilege [392-2] (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 415     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 10/28/02 of reply in support of dfts motion for leave to

                 reopen limited discovery and an ord finding a subject

                 matter waiver of the atty-client privilege; supplemental

                 declar of Kelly M. Klaus in suppt of dft motion for lv. (ca)

                 [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 416     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine  to exclude any evidence to contradict Ninth

                 Circuit's holding that Philadelphia Church of God used

                 mystery of the ages as a marketing device. Lodged Proposed

                 Order (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 417     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine to exclude evidence regarding worldwide

                 church of God's religious beliefs. Lodged Proposed Order (ca)

                 [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 418     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine re: arguments concerning Worldwide Church of

                 God's publicaton of the subject works. Lodged Proposed

                 Order (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 44  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

10/28/02 419     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine re: exclusion of 22,395 pages of documents

                 produced after discovery cut off by Philadelphia Church of

                 God. Lodged Proposed Order (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 420     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine to exclude evidence/argument re: whether or

                 not Worldwide Church of God will license the subject works.

                  Lodged Proposed Order (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 421     EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS filed by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God to materials submitted in support of dft & cnt-clm's

                 opposition to motions for s/j and 1st and 2nd counterclaims

                 for relief [406-1] (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 424     PROOF OF PERSONAL SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 on 10/28/02 of (see attached service list) (ca)

                 [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 425     NOTICE OF MOTIONS AND MOTIONS NO. 1-4 by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church for hearing at pretrial conference; in

                 limine #1 (evidence of tithes, offerings, and donations); in

                 limine #2 (Crissey profits report); in limine #3 (Rintala

                 report on how to construe Copyright Act); in limine #4

                 (requests and/or ofers to pay for subject Works from WCG);

                 Lodged Proposed Order (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 426     MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church in support of motion in limine #1

                 (evidence of tithes, offerings, and donations) [425-1] (ca)

                 [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 428     MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church in support of motion in limine #3

                 (Rintala report on how to construe the copyright act)

                 [425-1]. (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 429     MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church in support of motion in limine #4

                 (Requests and/or offers to pay for subject works form WCG)

                 [425-1]. (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 430     DECLARATION of Kelly M. Klaus by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God  in support of motion in limine 1-4 for hearing at

                 pretrial conference. [425-1] (ca) [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 431     DECLARATION of Gerald Flurry by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in support of motion in limine #1 (Evidence of

                 tithes, offerings, and donatins) [425-1]. (ca)

                 [Entry date 10/29/02]

 

10/28/02 434     PROOF OF SERVICE by hand by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 on 10/28/02 of (see attached service list) (ca)

                 [Entry date 10/29/02]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 45  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

10/29/02 435     ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder hearing on motions for

                 summary judgment [385-1] [384-1] will be held at 12:00

                 11/6/02; Parties will file & serve their reply briefs &

                 supporting papers by hand on 10/30/02; Parties memorandum

                 of fact & law, witness lists & preliminary joint exhibit

                 list will be filed & served on 11/8/02 (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/31/02]

 

10/30/02 436     NOTICE of Entry of Order granting Dft & Cntclm Philadelphia

                 Church of God Inc's Ex Parte Application for leave to file

                 a Consolidated opposition to Plf's motions for summary

                 judgment on 1st & 2nd Counterclaims for relief by defendant

                 & counter-claimant Philadelphia Church (ir)

                 [Entry date 10/31/02]

 

10/30/02 437     NOTICE OF ERRATA by plaintiff Worldwide Church God to

                 Worldwide Church of God's Reply brief in support of

                 Worldwide Church of God's motions for summary judgment on

                 (1) Fair Use & (2) RFRA (ir) [Entry date 10/31/02]

 

11/1/02  438     DESIGNATION of Rebuttal Experts filed by Plf Worldwide

                 Church of God (ir) [Entry date 11/04/02]

 

11/4/02  439     OPPOSITION by Philadelphia Church to motion in limine to

                 exclude evidence/argument re: whether or not Worldwide

                 Church of God will license the subject works. [420-1] (lc)

                 [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  440     OPPOSITION by Philadelphia Church to motion in limine re:

                 arguments concerning Worldwide Church of God's publicaton

                 the subject works. [418-1] (lc) [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  441     OPPOSITION by Philadelphia Church to motion in limine to

                 exclude evidence regarding worldwide church of God's

                 religious beliefs. [417-1] (lc) [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  443     OPPOSITION by Philadelphia Church to motion in limine to

                 exclude any evidence to contradict Ninth Circuit's holding

                 that Philadelphia Church of God used mystery of the ages as

                 a marketing device. [416-1] (lc) [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  444     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in limine # 5 re sincerity or religious nature of

                 PCG beliefs (lc) [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  444     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant Philadelphia

                 Church in limine #6 re references to race (lc)

                 [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  445     MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT by defendant Philadelphia Church  of

                 motion in limine # 5 re sincerity or religious nature of

                 PCG beliefs [444-1] (lc) [Entry date 11/05/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 46  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

11/4/02  446     MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT by defendant Philadelphia Church  of

                 motion in limine #6 re references to race [444-1] (lc)

                 [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  447     DECLARATION of Kelly M Klaus in suppt by Philadelphia

                 Church re motion in limine # 5 re sincerity or religious

                 nature of PCG beliefs [444-1],  motion in limine #6 re

                 references to race [444-1] (lc) [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  448     DECLARATION  of Kelly M Klaus in suppt of opp by defendant

                 Philadelphia Church re  motion in limine to exclude

                 evidence/argument re: whether or not Worldwide Church of

                 God will license the subject works. [420-1],  motion in

                 limine re: exclusion of 22,395 pages of documents produced

                 after discovery cut off by Philadelphia Church of God.

                 [419-1], motion in limine re: arguments concerning

                 Worldwide Church of God's publicaton of the subject works.

                 [418-1],  motion in limine to exclude evidence regarding

                 worldwide church of God's religious beliefs. [417-1],

                 motion in limine  to exclude any evidence to contradict

                 Ninth Circuit's holding that Philadelphia Church of God

                 used mystery of the ages as a marketing device. [416-1] (lc)

                 [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/4/02  451     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church on

                 11/4/02 of Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in

                 Limine to exclude any evidence to contradict ninth

                 circuit's holding that Philadelphia Church of God used

                 Mystery of the Ages as a Marketing Device (see doc for fur

                 details) (mch) [Entry date 11/08/02]

 

11/4/02  455     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine to exclude evidence (1) that Worldwide

                 Church of God does not own the copyright to the subject,

                 (2) that Herbert Armstrong gave an implied license to

                 Philadelphia Church of God or to any one else to use the

                 subject works and (3) testimony of Sealy M. Yates Lodged

                 supplemental (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  456     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine to exclude evidence pertaining to prior

                 litigation involving California's Attorney General. Lodged

                 Proposed Order (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  457     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine re: Philadelphia Church of God's attempted

                 or actual communications with counsel. Lodged Proposed

                 Order (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  458     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine  to exclude improper portions of expert

                 report & testimony of Philadelphia Church of God's

                 "Religion Expert" J. Gordon Melton. Lodged Proposed Order

                 (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 47  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

11/4/02  459     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine  to exclude any evidence that the preface to

                 the subject works is burdensome to Philadelphia Church of

                 God's Religion. Lodged Proposed Order. (ca)

                 [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  460     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine to exclude Philadelphia Church of God's

                 duplicative expert witness testimony. Lodged Proposed

                 Order (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  461     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by plaintiff Worldwide Church

                 God in limine re: "Unfairness of Philadelphia Church of

                 God Inc.'s monetary contributions being paid in damages to

                 Worldwide Church of God. Lodged Proposed Order (ca)

                 [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  462     MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES filed by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God in opposition to motion in limine #3

                 (Rintala Report). [425-1] (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  463     MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES filed by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God in opposition to motion in limine No.

                 4 (Requests and offers to pay Worldwide Church of God for

                 subject works).  [425-1] (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/4/02  464     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God on

                 11/4/02 of (see service list) by mail & by personal service

                 (ca) [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/5/02  442     OPPOSITION by Philadelphia Church  to  motion in limine re:

                 exclusion of 22,395 pages of documents produced after

                 discovery cut off by Philadelphia Church of God. [419-1] (lc)

                 [Entry date 11/05/02]

 

11/6/02  449     STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder that the

                 opposition & reply briefs for the motions to be heard on

                 11/18/02 & 11/25/02 which would normally be due on 11/11/02

                 may be filed with the Court no later than 1:00 pm on

                 Tuesday 11/12/02 (ir) [Entry date 11/08/02]

 

11/6/02  452     MINUTES: Plf's motion for summary judgment re PCG's 2nd

                 Claim for Declaratory Relief (Fair Use) [385-1] (Filed

                 9/30/02) & Dft's motion for leave to reopen limited

                 discovery [392-1] & an order finding a subject matter

                 waiver of the attorney-client privilege [392-2] (Filed

                 10/15/02); Court heard argument on the above motions; Court

                 took motions under submission IT IS SO ORDERED by Judge

                 Christina A. Snyder CR: Laur Elias (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/08/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 48  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

11/6/02  453     MINUTES: Court hereby continues all motion in limine

                 [444-1], [444-1] [425-1], [420-1], [419-1], [418-1],

                 [417-1], [416-1] set for hearing on 11/18/02 to 10:00

                 11/25/02 IT IS SO ORDERED by Judge Christina A. Snyder CR:

                 Laura Elias (ir) [Entry date 11/08/02]

 

11/6/02  468     WITNESS list submitted by defendant Philadelphia Church (ca)

                 [Entry date 11/12/02]

 

11/8/02  469     DECLARATION of Miles J. Feldman by plaintiff Worldwide

                 Church God in support of motion in limine re: "Unfairness

                 of Philadelphia Church of God Inc.'s monetary contributions

                 being paid in damages to Worldwide Church of God. [461-1]

                 (ca) [Entry date 11/13/02]

 

11/8/02  470     WITNESS list submitted by plaintiff Worldwide Church God (ca)

                 [Entry date 11/13/02]

 

11/12/02 472     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion in

                 limine to exclude Philadelphia Church of God's duplicative

                 expert witness testimony. [460-1] (bp) [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 473     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion in

                 limine  to exclude any evidence that the preface to the

                 subject works is burdensome to Philadelphia Church of God's

                 Religion. [459-1] (bp) [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 474     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion in

                 limine to exclude evidence (1) that Worldwide Church of God

                 does not own the copyright to the subject, (2) that Herbert

                 Armstrong gave an implied license to Philadelphia Church of

                 God or to any one else to use the subject works and (3)

                 testimony of Sealy M. Yates [455-1] (bp)

                 [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 475     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion in

                 limine re: "Unfairness of Philadelphia Church of God Inc.'s

                 monetary contributions being paid in damages to Worldwide

                 Church of God. [461-1] (bp) [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 476     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion in

                 limine to exclude improper portions of expert report &

                 testimony of Philadelphia Church of God's "Religion Expert"

                 J. Gordon Melton. [458-1] (bp) [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 477     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion in

                 limine re: Philadelphia Church of God's attempted or actual

                 communications with counsel. [457-1] (bp)

                 [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 478     OPPOSITION by defendant Philadelphia Church to motion in

                 limine to exclude evidence pertaining to prior litigation

                 involving California's Attorney General. [456-1] (bp)

                 [Entry date 11/14/02]


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 49  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

 

11/12/02 479     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church on

                 11/12/02 of opposition to motions in limine. (bp)

                 [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 480     MEMORANDUM of Points & Authorities filed by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God in opposition to motion in limine # 5

                 re sincerity or religious nature of PCG beliefs [444-1] (bp)

                 [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/12/02 481     MEMORANDUM of Points & Authorities filed by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church God in opposition to motion in limine #6

                 re references to race [444-1] (bp) [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/13/02 483     ORIGINAL PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God

                 on 11/12/02 of Ex Parte Application to have motion in

                 limine for Order excluding extremely late produced

                 documents (filed under seal) (ir) [Entry date 11/15/02]

 

11/14/02 471     MINUTES: Telephonic Status Conference; Status conference

                 hearing held; Parties shall have until 11/20/02 to file the

                 Memorandum of Fact & Law & Pretrial Conference Order;

                 Additionally parties shall file the exhibit list & any

                 objections thereto on the 1st day of trial IT IS SO ORDERED

                 by Judge Christina A. Snyder CR: Laura Elias (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/14/02]

 

11/14/02 482     ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder Plf's motion for summary

                 judgment re PCG's 1st Claim for Declaratory Relief

                 (Religious Freedom Restoration Act) [384-1] & motion for

                 summary judgment re PCG's 2nd Claim for Declaratory Relief

                 (Fair Use) [385-1] i is DENIED without prejudice; Dft's

                 motion for leave to reopen limited discovery [392-1], & an

                 order finding a subject matter waiver of the

                 attorney-client privilege [392-2] is DENIED (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/15/02]

 

11/15/02 485     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 11/06/02 (Re:), CR: Laura Miller Elias. (wdc)

                 [Entry date 11/18/02]

 

11/15/02 --      TRANSCRIPT filed for proceedings held on 11/06/02. (wdc)

                 [Entry date 11/18/02]

 

11/18/02 486     REPLY memorandum by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 support of motion in limine # 5 re sincerity or religious

                 nature of PCG beliefs [444-1] (tw) [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 487     REPLY memorandum by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 support of motion in limine #6 re references to race

                 [444-1] (tw) [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 488     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church  on

                 11/18/02  of reply memorandum, etc (tw)


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 50  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 489     REPLY by plaintiffs in support of  motion in limine to

                 exclude evidence (1) that Worldwide Church of God does not

                 own the copyright to the subject, (2) that Herbert

                 Armstrong gave an implied license to Philadelphia Church of

                 God or to any one else to use the subject works and (3)

                 testimony of Sealy M. Yates [455-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 490     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine  to exclude any evidence that the

                 preface to the subject works is burdensome to Philadelphia

                 Church of God's Religion. [459-1] (tw) [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 491     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine to exclude Philadelphia Church of

                 God's duplicative expert witness testimony. [460-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 492     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine re: Philadelphia Church of God's

                 attempted or actual communications with counsel. [457-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 493     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine re: "Unfairness of Philadelphia Church

                 of God Inc.'s monetary contributions being paid in damages

                 to Worldwide Church of God. [461-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 494     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine to exclude evidence/argument re:

                 whether or not Worldwide Church of God will license the

                 subject works. [420-1] (tw) [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 495     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine to exclude evidence pertaining to

                 prior litigation involving California's Attorney General.

                 [456-1] (tw) [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 496     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine  to exclude improper portions of

                 expert report & testimony of Philadelphia Church of God's

                 "Religion Expert" J. Gordon Melton. [458-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 497     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine to exclude evidence regarding

                 worldwide church of God's religious beliefs. [417-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 51  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

11/18/02 498     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 motion in limine re: arguments concerning Worldwide Church

                 of God's publicaton of the subject works. [418-1] (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 499     REPLY brief by plaintiff Worldwide Church God in support of

                 its motion in limine re: exclusion of 22,395 pages of

                 documents produced after discovery cut off by Philadelphia

                 Church of God. [419-1] (tw) [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 500     PROOF OF SERVICE by plaintiff Worldwide Church God  on

                 11/18/02  of replies in support of its motions in limine (tw)

                 [Entry date 11/19/02]

 

11/18/02 503     REPLY MEMORANDUM by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 support of motion in limine #1 (evidence of tithes,

                 offerings, and donations) [425-1] (jp) [Entry date 11/20/02]

 

11/18/02 504     REPLY MEMORANDUM by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 support of motion in limine #2 (Crissey profits report)

                 [425-1] (jp) [Entry date 11/20/02]

 

11/18/02 505     REPLY MEMORANDUM by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 support of motion in limine #3 (Rintala report on how to

                 construe Copyright Act) [425-1] (jp) [Entry date 11/20/02]

 

11/18/02 506     REPLY MEMORANDUM by defendant Philadelphia Church in

                 support of motion in limine #4 (requests and/or ofers to

                 pay for subject Works from WCG) [425-1] (jp)

                 [Entry date 11/20/02]

 

11/20/02 507     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by defendant Philadelphia Church

                 for order shortening time for hearing on its motion in

                 limine No 7; Declaration of Kelly M. Klaus; Lodged

                 Proposed Order; Notice of Motion & Memorandum of Points and

                 Authorities (mch) [Entry date 11/21/02]

 

11/20/02 508     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant Philadelphia Church on

                 11/20/02 of Notice of Motion & Motion in Limine No. 7;

                 Memorandum of Points and Authorities in support (see

                 document for further details) (mch) [Entry date 11/21/02]

 

11/21/02 509     STIPULATION and ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder that

                 parties' memorandu of fact & law will be filed & served on

                 11/22/02; Parties proposed pretrial conference order will

                 be lodged on 11/22/02; Date for parties' reply briefs to

                 the memorandum of fact & law will be set at the pretrial

                 conference on 11/25/02 (ir) [Entry date 11/22/02]

 

11/22/02 510     RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT of proceedings for the following

                 date(s): 11/8/02, 11/14/02   CR: Laura Elias (dl)

                 [Entry date 11/25/02]

 

11/22/02 --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 11/8/02 (dl)


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 52  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                 [Entry date 11/25/02]

 

11/22/02 --      TRANSCRIPT filed  for proceedings held on 11/14/02 (dl)

                 [Entry date 11/25/02]

 

11/22/02 511     MEMORANDUM OF CONTENTIONS OF FACT and LAW by plaintiff

                 Worldwide Church of God (ir) [Entry date 11/25/02]

 

11/22/02 514     EX PARTE APPLICATION filed by defendant & counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church for leave to file an oversized

                 memorandum of Contentions of Fact & Law; Lodged Proposed

                 Order & Lodged Proposed memo (ir) [Entry date 11/26/02]

 

11/22/02 517     PROOF OF SERVICE by defendant & counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church on 11/22/02 of Dft & Counterclaimant

                 Philadelphia Church of God Inc's Ex Parte Application for

                 leave to file an oversized memorandum of Contentions of

                 Fact & law (See document for further details) (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/26/02]

 

11/25/02 512     MINUTES: The Court heard brief argument on the motions in

                 limine; The Court continued all motions in limine [444-1],

                 [444-1], [425-1], [420-1], [419-1], [418-1], [417-1],

                 [416-1] that were set for hearing on 11/25/02, to 12/18/02

                 at 9:30 am; Further briefs may be filed as it relates to

                 the motions re experts; The Court orders that each brief

                 should not exceed the 25 page limit; Further, the Court

                 continues the trial schedule based on plf's trial schedule

                 conflict; Trial is continued from 12/3/02, to 3/4/03, at

                 9:30 am; The pretrial conf is continued to 2/3/03, at 11:00

                 am by Judge Christina A. Snyder; CR: Laura Elias (nhac)

                 [Entry date 11/26/02]

 

11/25/02 513     MINUTES: Philadelphia Church of God's ex parte application

                 to shorten time on motion in limine No 7 (lost sales and

                 diminution of copyright value calculations) [507-1] is

                 hereby denied as moot; Counsel in open court stipulated to

                 hear the motion on 12/23/02, at 10:00 am; Opposition to the

                 motion is due on 12/9/02; A reply may be filed by 12/16/02

                 by Judge Christina A. Snyder; CR: Laura Elias (nhac)

                 [Entry date 11/26/02]

 

11/25/02 515     NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION by defendant & counter-claimant

                 Philadelphia Church in limine No 7 to exclude re Lost

                 Sales & Diminution of Copyright Value Calculations (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/26/02]

 

11/25/02 516     MEMORANDUM of Points & Authorities by defendant &

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church in support of motion

                 in limine No 7 to exclude re Lost Sales & Diminution of

                 Copyright Value Calculations [515-1]; Declaration of Mark B

                 Helm (ir) [Entry date 11/26/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 53  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

11/26/02 518     ORDER by Judge Christina A. Snyder GRANTING Dft-Cntclmt's

                 ex parte application for leave to file an oversized

                 memorandum of Contentions of Fact & Law [514-1]; PCG is

                 permitted to file an oversized memorandum of Contentions of

                 fact & Law (ir) [Entry date 11/26/02]

 

11/26/02 519     MEMORANDUM OF CONTENTIONS OF FACT and LAW by defendant &

                 counter-claimant Philadelphia Church of God Inc (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/27/02]

 

11/26/02 520     MINUTES: Plf Worldwide Church of God's Ex Parte Application

                 to have motion in limine for Order excluding extremely late

                 produced documents (Filed 11/13/02); At oral argument

                 counsel for WCG conceded that due to the continuance of the

                 trial date until 3/4/03 any prejudice to WCG arising from

                 the late production of the documents at issued in this ex

                 parte motion is remedied by WCG now having time to review

                 the documents & to reopen discovery if necessary; Thus this

                 ex parte motion for an orde in limine to exclude the

                 documents for late discovery is moot; However this ruling

                 does not preclude WCG from later raising objections to the

                 admissibility of the documents on grounds other than late

                 production by Judge Christina A. Snyder (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/27/02]

 


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 54  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

11/27/02 521     MINUTES: Plf's motion in limine to exclude any evidence to

                 contradict Ninth Circuit's holding that Philadelphia Church

                 of God used mystery of the ages as a marketing device

                 [416-1] is denied; Plf's motion in limine to exclude

                 evidence regarding Worldwide Church of God's religious

                 beliefs [417-1] is granted in part & denied in part; Plf's

                 motion in limine re: arguments concerning Worldwide Church

                 of publicaton of MOA & the Non MOA Works [418-1] is denied

                 without prejudice; These maters appear to be arguments that

                 the parties may be entitled to assert in some circumstances;

                  Plf's motion in limine re: exclusion of 22,395 pages of

                 documents produced after discovery cut off by Philadelphia

                 Church of God [419-1] i is moot; However this ruling does

                 not preclude WCG from later raising objections to the

                 admissibility of the documents on grounds other than later

                 production; Plf's motion in limine to exclude

                 evidence/argument re: whether or not Worldwide Church of

                 God will license the subject works (only the non-MOA Works)

                 [420-1] is granted in part & denied in part; Plf's motion

                 in limine re: Philadelphia of God's attempted or actual

                 communications with counsel [457-1] is granted; Plf's

                 motion in limine to exclude evidence pertaining to prior

                 litigation involving California's Attorney General [456-1]

                 is granted; Plf's motion in limine re: "Unfairness of

                 Philadelphia Church of God Inc.'s monetary contributions

                 being paid in damages to Worldwide Church of God [461-1] is

                 granted; Plf's motion in limine to exclude improper

                 portions of expert report & testimony Philadelphia Church

                 of God's "Religion Expert" J. Gordon Melton [458-1] is

                 granted in part & denied in part; Plf's motion in limine to

                 exclude any evidence that the preface to MOA & the Non-MOA

                 Works is Burdensome to PCG's Religion [459-1] is denied

                 without prejudice to it being renewed at trial; Plf's

                 motion in limine to exclude Philadelphia Church of God's

                 duplicative expert witness testimony [460-1] is denied

                 without prejudice to it being renewed at trial; Plf's

                 motion in limine to exclude evidence (1) that Worldwide

                 Church of God does not own the copyright to the subject,

                 (2) that Herbert Armstrong gave an implied license to

                 Philadelphia Church of God or to any one else to use the

                 subject works and (3) testimony of Sealy M. Yates [455-1]

                 is granted in part & denied in part; Dft's motion in limine

                 #1 to exclude evidence of tithes, offerings, and donations

                 made to PCG Allegedly as the Result of its Distribution of

                 MOA [425-1] is granted in part & denied in part; Dft's

                 motion in limine No 2 to exclude the John T Crissey Expert

                 Report or any testimony by him, calculating or referring to

                 any donations, cotributions, Tithes or other offerings made

                 to PCG allegedly as the result of its Distribution to MOA

                 or Any "Profits" or Monetary Benefit PCG Allegedly obtained

                 as a result; Dft's motion in limine No 3 to exclude

                 evidence of William T Rintala's expert report or any

                 testimony by him, regarding a proper Construction &

                 Application of the Copyright Act is granted; Dft's motion


 

 

Docket as of November 27, 2002 7:26 pm               Page 55  

 

Proceedings include all events.                                   REOPEN

2:97cv5306 Worldwide Church God v. Philadelphia Church                   (CWx)

 

                 in limine No 4 to exclude any evidence of requests &/or

                 offers to pay for copies of MOA & the Non-MOA Works from

                 WCG is denied; Dft's motion in limine # 5 to exclude

                 evidence with respect to the Sincerity of PCG's Religious

                 beliefs [444-1] is granted in part & denied in part; Dft's

                 motion in limine #6 to exclude evidence of the Views of the

                 PCG or Herbert Armstrong on any Matters Related to Race,

                 any alleged Racially Insensitive Contents of Armstrong's

                 Writings as a Basis for the WCG Having Discontinued them or

                 the WCG's efforts at "Reconciliation" with other races or

                 faiths following his death [444-1] is granted in part &

                 denied in part (See document for further details) IT IS SO

                 ORDERED by Judge Christina A. Snyder CR: Laura Elias (ir)

                 [Entry date 11/27/02]

 

[END OF DOCKET: 2:97cv5306]

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

                         PACER Service Center                             

                         Transaction Receipt                              

 

                         12/02/2002 18:45:40

 

PACER Login:  sm1452         Client Code:                                 

Description:  docket report  Search Criteria:  2:97cv05306                    

Billable Pages:          55  Cost:   3.85

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

 

 

 

 

            Do you Yahoo!?

            Yahoo! Tax Center - forms, calculators, tips, and more